Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Hmm... I'm a bit confused over the speculation as I can't see the sense there... Let's make a quick eyeing on the rules first...
Now obviously we wouldn't lynch the hunter if s/he revealed during the Day as there is the possibility of an innocent going down. It would ease our choice though for who to lynch: one less to choose from. The downside would be that the wolves would not kill her/him either so we'd face the "believability problem" once again.
With a rivalling call we'd need to be careful as lynching the wrong one would once again make the possibility of an extra innocent dying possible.
Although to be honest, if a hunter doesn't get it right having three chances out of six possibilities, then it's a bit ad hunting...
But anyway, it's for the hunter (and ranger - they can talk, wasn't it so?) to decide.
|
Good point (the underlining) but make sure to take my view into consideration.
Not to be rude, but a living hunter is a useless hunter. Whether or not they have their picks right we'll learn something. In fact we can advise them on how to pick if we want, though of course it is their choice in the end. I'd at least be willing to give it a shot, assuming they do indeed decide to come out. It'd teach us a lot about the alignment of people, based on how they reacted to lynching the hunter once they discovered their list, etc. The only way to find out is to try?
EDIT: Didn't realize Nogrod had x'd with me, so I'll let him think it over before I respond further.
