About the
Nerwen edit thing: much as I'm inclined to respect her wish not to see it blown out of proportion, turning the matter into a 'sign of innocence', as
Tewie does in #49, is too much. After last game, I'm not sure there's
anything I'd put beyond a
Nerwolf. Not going to vote her without some better reason, though.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Legate #46
Also when re-reading, I became worried about TEWie-Sally and such discussions in the beginning... I mean "happy band of Wolves goes to picnic, what will we do in the first hours of Day 1 when nothing much is happening, let's have a chat". Of course, that would mean that they would have to be packmates.
|
As if most games didn't start with banter like that for the first 10-15 posts. I'm not saying ignore it all - there can be valuable hints in banter, like a cobbler signalling to wolves or self-conscious "I'm-so-evil" jokes - , but seeing a happy wolf chat just because there
was some banter, regardless of content, is stretching it.
(Btw,
Zil, I explicitely
did applaud
Legate in my very first post. Remains to be seen whether that was premature or not.)
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro
Both wolf packs have a seer, making a fake reveal inevitable, as well as easily convincing and more believable.
|
And at the same time making a genuine reveal by our own Seer rather risky, especially after this here:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by sally
That being said, I don't think we should trust our seer. I mean we should, but even a wolf seer could hand over wolves (of course from the other pack, but still) and we'd never know the difference.
|
Again, this is obviously true, but what's the point of stating it, except to sow mistrust of
any Seer revealing, including our own?
But if you're asking for 'attack plans' in case of reveals, we should consider the possibility that the person revealing isn't necessarily the true Seer (innocent or wolvish), but a Hunter acting as mouthpiece for the real Seer in order to attract a Night-kill. The wolf-pack with a Hunterwolf could easily do this (they know each other's gifts, of course), but unless I'm mistaken about the current version of the Rules, our own gifteds could do it as well once the Seer has dreamed the Hunter.
EDIT: x-ed w/
Boro,
sally &
Kit