Now, naturally we have no guarantee
Greenie dreamt a wolf at all. However, since she stated suspicion of
Nogrod yesterDay, and indeed voted him, and since
Nogrod was starting to creep me out towards the end of yesterDay, I think he's worth looking at. Besides, he's been under my radar most of the game.
Nogrod, Day One
#33
Banter; is "uneasy" with
Lottie:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
For the Duchess surely goes into that infamous mode of "no bad person, even insane one, would do that kind of a thing" - like screaming "Go wolves!" on D1...
|
Comments: This post follows
Fea's unexplained vote on
Lottie– perhaps opportunistic? The mention of
Poison Ivy-Nerwolf also seems perhaps a trifle insidious– like it's trying to create guilt-by-association. To be fair, though, the "Arkham Asylum" game must still be fresh in peoples minds, and
Nogrod wasn't the only one to claim to find
Lottie's songs questionable at this point–
Zil and
Nienna did too. (
Fea, presumeably, didn't.)
#60
Ask for real names to be used; finds a post of
Shasta's (not indicated) "unreadable"; says that
Agan's comment about the Seer not being 100% reliable (because of the Cursed) is not helpful so early in the game and that she seems overly worried about her image.
–Jumps on
Zil for saying
wintywinty's vote should be scrutinized, finding it a typically wolfish statement.
–Dismisses
Lottie's explanation that she wrote the songs before getting her role:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
It's not so much about when you wrote that piece of ambiguity, but what was your role when you decided it was a good way to start posting?
|
#85
Dismisses
Zil's explanation for his use of "scrutiny", elaborates on why it's so suspicious– apparently because the vote cannot in itself reveal
ww's role.
Comments: This is
complete hair-splitting, and is in fact quite a weird reason to go after someone. As I said yesterDay (or the Day before, I forget) it could be a language-problem– i.e.
Nogrod taking things too literally.
#99
Discusses rules and the retraction-issue, is perturbed by
Lottie-wagon, though at the same time he does not find her at all innocent-looking.
Comments: Hmmn. Seems like he wants it both ways...
#108
Compares the people voting for
Lottie (
Fea,
Lommy and
Greenie at that point) to the retraction-dumpers (
Sally and Aganzir), and wonders if it's just herd-mentality or something more.
Comments: Looking for reasons to suspect as many people as possible? Perhaps– mind you, both of those affairs
were worth commenting on. He does exaggerate, saying "a band" of people had used their retrackies when only two had.
#115
Quotes Inzil's latest defence, but appears not to accept it... though he also says the affair is "running out of proportion". Says he now has an opinion on
Zil, but does not state it.
Comments: Uh... *scratches head* Really, I don't know what to make of that post at all. What is he trying to say?
#119. Tells
Skip how to highlight votes.
#128
Suspicion list. With the exception of
Izzy (trusted) and Skip ("making a lot of sense") is non-committal about
everyone. Now also concerned about the
save-
Lottie-wagon.
Comments: Okaay.
This post is quite wolfy-looking–
Nog's at pains to leave himself room either to suspect or not suspect virtually
the entire village. Yes, it was Day One, but still...
#137
Suggests
Fea and
Lottie may be a cobbler and wolf testing each other out. Votes
Fea (Fea 2), because though he suspects them both, he suspects her more.
Comments: *shrugs* Perfectly reasonable vote-post. Nothing to say about it.
General Remarks: Well, while #128 is the only single post I'd call definitely furry-looking, from
Nog's overall Day One posting I shouldn't be that *surprised* if he turns out a wolf. I won't put it stronger than that– later Days may give a different picture. Also, I haven't yet looked at what the known wolves said about him– as I recall, not much.
I have to go now, but when I come back I'll look at
Nogrod on Days 2 and 3 and at
Sallywolf and
Glirwolf's relations with him, if no-one has in the meantime.
EDIT:X'd with a host.