Quote:
|
Originally Posted by elbenprincess
Did Yavanna gave Olorin the elessar especially for galadriel (I know at some point she was supposed to give it another person, but at this point, was it meant to be for galadriel) ? If it is the case, it is really amazing that a VALAR!!! thinks of galadriel that way
|
Hmm, Gandalf ultimately does say:
'This I give to you from Yavanna', so maybe, but why she would need it to keep things from
fading, when she can use Nenya at this point in time, is difficult to say however.
Perhaps Tolkien
meant this version of the tale to be considered false by the reader (referring to:
'In ages after there was again an Elessar, and of this two things are said, though which is true only those Wise could say who now are gone.' from earlier in the text), or externally, maybe Tolkien just made a mistake in a rough draft that happened to survive for us Tolkien fans.
This text is, in any event, a very rough draft, mainly in the first stage of composition.