Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerwen
I haven't forgotten last game– but that was such a different situation I didn't think it was even worth taking into account.
|
Fair enough. And in fact I was saying the same thing. I think it's perfectly logical to fake seer in order to save the seer or to put yourself in more danger in order to protect them, but I don't think
Phantom had the reasoning or timing to do so.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nerwen
I am frustrated with Phantom– less with the actual ploy, whatever it is, than with his attitude that nothing he does should be questioned.
|
Meh, understandable. I don't think he's a cleared innocent either, but I must say....I think him not voting may actually speak more to his innocence than if he had voted
Lottie at Day's end. Shocking, you say? Scandalous? Not really.
Let's say
Phantom is a SoB....erm, SoE. *headdesks, couldn't resist* Knowing that
Phantom is a dirty, lowdown, double-crossing scumbag (with love, dear), he would likely be happy to vote for a packmate. It would make him look good, in fact. Thus, why wouldn't he just pile his votes on and say "look at me, I killed
Lottie" and add to his train of Reasons Not to Suspect
Phantom? It would make sense to do so, and while yes, some people would likely call him out and say "but you didn't kill her, in fact she was already dead before you voted", he would still look good to the masses, his "vote me and I won't vote you" pledge aside.
Basically, a wolf!
Phantom would bus his packmate if he got the chance and it was really advantageous for him to do so. I'm not saying he would kill a packmate
just because he fancied it, but I feel that he would double cross a fellow wolf/elf/thing if the situation had desired benefits.
Especially if said packmate was already dead, or mostly dead, or whatever.
Granted, I'm not saying that I trust
Phantom completely, because he could have thought of all the above beforehand and predicted that I (or someone else) would say this exact thing in his defense, but I think that voting for
Lottie would have, in that case, looked actually worse than not voting at all.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nerwen
Er– hang on. I thought he meant, " YesterDay I would have rather Sally had been lynched", not "I now wish Lottie hadn't been lynched". You reckon that's what he meant?  |
I think he meant a bit of both, at least subconsciously? I think he means that yesterDay he would have preferred to see me lynched, and he still feels that way toDay. More of a preference to having me dead than an outright attitude of "I wish
Lottie was still alive", but the undertones -subtext, for
Shasta's enjoyment- still remain the same. He wasn't happy with yesterDay's lynch, and that makes me nervous.
EDIT: x'd since my last, and attempting to fix all my bolding/italics because Chrome is hateful
