Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sally
Okay, so we know Phantom's not the seer, because....well, he's not and stuff, so the reveal at the end of yesterDay was likely either to protect the seer (for which we should all thank him, because we love our seer, don't we?) or to make it look like he was so he could get a pass toDay. Really, though, I don't think he would do that as a wolf, at least not on the first Day and without at least some reasoning he could point at to avoid getting lynched.
|
This and your argument about phantom's failing to vote being a point in his favour are both too... conjectural for my taste. Too much depend on your ability to predict what he'd do.
Case in point:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sally
he would likely be happy to vote for a packmate. It would make him look good, in fact. Thus, why wouldn't he just pile his votes on and say "look at me, I killed Lottie" and add to his train of Reasons Not to Suspect Phantom?
|
Funny thing is, though– phantom himself says earlier that he
would never do that.
You see, he argues that it's in his favour, too, but for the exact opposite reason.
Actually, there
are a couple of points in his favour: one is the rather obvious one that what he did was practically a request to get himself dreamed. The other is more subtle and indeed tenuous – the way
Lottie kept responding to questions about her own behaviour with defences of
tp, though it's true the two were related– framing attempt? It's possible.