During lunch break, I read some of Day2, and most of what I read was the ongoing discussion between
Nerwen and
Phantom. I am not quite sure what to make of it all, but as you two are fairly constant players, I figured I may as well ask the questions that were bothering me...
Nerwen, why did you press Phantom so hard about being the seer? It seemed very important to you that he have an explenation for making his last minute seer-confesion/reveal thing on Day 1. Why so? Were you trying to decipher whether or not he really WAS the seer? Why was it so important to you? If you think it links him to an elf, then say so, please.
At first I thought your split vote on day 1 was suspcious, but after considering it for a while I think that this was an un-elvish thing to do, because if you had wanted to save Lottie, who at that point had three votes and I don't think anyone else did, you could've given both your votes to Sally or something like that. I can't remember numbers exactly.
But harping on and on about Phantom seems strange to me. Please explain.
While looking through Day1, I found something which strengthens my opinion that
Inzil is not an elf:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Inzil post 225
That's the way I see the Sally and Lottie votes too. I don't know whether tp is a SoE, but I flat-out disagree with him on this. And it feels likely that there's a SoE among the three of them.
|
I don't think an elf would draw attention to that. If anything, they'd try to draw attention away. Or...as
Mirandir did, join in the fray without really drawing any guilty attention to herself. Why is she considered clear of the radar? Because in the past, Mir has acted crazily excited when she's bad? Hm...
Phantom, how is it you've missed voting so many times this game? That's insane.
In all honesty, I don't think he is guilty. I think if he had been, he would've tried to save Lottie. I know Nerwen said, "baddies have said before, "if I were a wolf, I wouldn't act in such a way" or "if I were a wolf, I would've done this."" but still....to let a fellow wolf get killed that first day? Seems risky and unloyal to me - unless there was some greater cause that she was being sacrificed for, which I don't currently see.
Quite honestly, I think we have a wolf among our quieter set of people. Good luck finding that stuff out.
So...that whole post to say:
Phantom - probably innocent
Inzil - probably innocent
Nerwen - a little questionmark, but also probably innocent.
Sorry I've got nothing better. My time is so scattered that my reading of the thread is scattered, too. It took me almost two hours to compose this post.
X-posted with Phantom
-- Foley