The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Werewolf LXXXI: Under the Misty Mountains

Thinlómien · 09-24-2010, 03:52 PM

Okay, decided not to look at Mira's posts myself as Zil quoted them all anyway and I think we've reached a conclusion on her dreams in any case. So off to other work...

Omitting our three known innocents...

~*~

LOTTIE

Legate

Legate about Lottie
Day1: #45 indirectly says Lottie and Sally's votes might've been out of lack of time, lack of imagination on d1 or SoE bandwagon hiding reasons.
#60 worries about Rune's buddying up with people and throws Lottie and Sally to the same category.
#68 agrees with Boro's criticism of Lottie and Sally.
#100 wouldn't vote her for a rep because of the tp-connection and (relative) absence.
#270 mentions her among several others as someone whose lynching he'd consider.

Lottie about Legate
- nothing -

Lommy

Lommy about Lottie
Day1: #46 does not "heart" Lottie and criticises her "stupid" rep vote.
#52 apologises to Sally and Lottie for possible offense.
#113 is annoyed by her and other tp-voters but doesn't have any "actual clear reasonable suspicions" against them.
#237 Lottie is in her worrisome half of the village.
#242 wonders about Lottie's change of mind considering tp and says that if he turns out to be a wolf, we should look at the people who rep-voted him.
#247 brings up Lottie's wolfy cheerfulness and voting first and coming up with reasons afterwards and wonders if she should change her mind about her.
#254 would like to vote Lottie (and possibly give 1/3 votes to Cel).
#264 wonders whether to give Lottie two or three votes.
#266 votes her with three votes. The first lynch vote to be given to anyone. Comments: "a bit less of a shot in the dark than most other options".

Lottie about Lommy
Day1: #306 defends herself against Lommy's points.

Zil

Zil about Lottie
Day1: #47 agrees with Lommy's criticism of Lottie and Sally's votes
#268 replies to Lommy's question saying he'd like to see one of phantom, Sally or Lottie dead, dislikes phantom's supporting the girls' votes for him.

Lottie about Zil
Day1: #175 corrects Folwren's misinformation on him
#187 explains her nicknames for him and Izzy

Folwren

Lottie about Folwren
Day1: #175 corrects her misinformation about Zil.
#189 defends tp against her point criticising the two of them and Sally.
#196 continues argueing with her to defend tp.

Folwren about Lottie
Day1: #188 says her and Sally's were not logical or worthwhile and wonders why tp doesn't see this.
#193 replies Lottie's defense in a slightly lecturing tone.
#239 says the "Sally-and-Lottie-baseless-votes-for-phantom issue" has been discussed enough. True, but it's funny how everything looks so suspicious taken out of context like this...

Eönwë

Eönwë about Lottie
Day1: #101 argues against her reasons for voting for tp as a rep.
#120 she is among the "other people" he has no idea bout yet.
#260 argues against her points again.
#267 would be annoyed if she, Sally and tp are all wolves but thinks it's likely there are Elves in the triangle.

Lottie about Eönwë
#306 counter-criticism against him.

Kath and Rune didn't have any interaction with Lottie. Which is quite weird given that she was the hot potato of the Day...

~*~

GREENIE

Lommy

Lommy about Greenie
Day1: #113 argues against her points, loves her, likes her and agrees with her but wonders if her vote was even too good, considers her for rep vote.
#118 votes Greenie for rep because they are "on the same wavelength". Haha, that sounds bad in the light of the current knowledge, doesn't it?
#209 thanks Shasta for taking up her and Greenie's crusade against tp.
#217 explains Greenie's internet-problems to the Cave.
#237 Greenie is in her not so worrisome half of the village.
#266 lets her use the computer.
Day2 #419 claims she can read her (and Legate and Rune) well and believes them all innocent. Wouldn't it be funny if Legate and Rune turned out to be wolves too?
#452 replies to her questioning her Wilwa comments.
#459 repeats claim of being able to read her and thinks her very innocent. Greenie must've been so gleeful reading my posts...
Day3 #557 starting to reconsider her previous opinion of Greenie and Legate but still more thinking them innocent.
#566 agrees with her about Rune's post being ironic.
#590 creeps herself out by half-seriously speculating a phantom-Greenie-Kath pack.
#632 answers Nerwen's question about her opinion on Legate and Greenie by: "And no idea about Greenie and Legate. Currently thinking Legate is probably innocent and very unsure about Greenie. "
#659 has started to suspect her quite randomly but has a bad feeling her suspicion is wrong, lists her under "difficult" with more than half of the remaining cavers. Speculates about a Shasta+Nerwen+Greenie pack but thinks Greenie+Nerwen unlikely.
#663 discusses the lynch options and prefers Shasta. "Zil/Nerwen/Greenie I'm torn about but I would possibly prefer Greenie... not sure at all."

Greenie about Lommy
Day1: #69 agrees with Lommy's points.
#76 says she seems genuine but isn't sure if she wants to vote her for a rep.
#79 explains Lommy's point to phantom.
#274 inclined to think her innocentish.
Day2: #357 delivers her message to the Cave.
#365 thinks her very innocent and partly because of her Lottie-vote.
#406 hands over the computer to her.
#448 asks her how can anyone (Wilwa) be fishy in an innocent way.
#462 clarifies Lommy's typo (by request).
#471 asks the Cave not to lynch Lommy, tp, Wilwa or Shasta.
Day3: #572 can't see her as an Elf, if she's an Elf she deserves to win.
#573 considers rep-voting her because she seems innocent.
#582 considering rep-votes: "I'm debating right now between phantom, Lommy, Rune and Zil."
#583 continues considering rep-votes: "Not Lommy. She, too, has already been a rep, and I don't think that much can be learned from her being one again."
#642 mentions her in a nerwielysis.

Zil

Greenie about Zil
Day1: #69 agrees with his point of witholding rep votes.
#76 can't read him yet but not alarmed.
Day2: #365 agonises about never being able to read him.
Day3: #572 thinks he's too smooth and can't read him. Anyone else thinking this repetition starts to go quite over the top...?
#573 considers him for rep because he hasn't been one yet and making him vote might reveal more of him.
#582 considering rep-votes: "I'm debating right now between phantom, Lommy, Rune and Zil."
#583 continues considering rep-votes: "Rune or Inzil for me, then. Both kind of shots in the dark. I'd like to know a bit more about both though."
#584 rep-votes him. "Because an innocent Inzil can make a good decision on my behalf, and an evil Inzil will hopefully be revealed. " Makes Zil looks worse than Rune.
#649 asks who Zil wants to lynch.
#652 has an uneasy feeling about him but won't vote him because she doesn't have "even half-decent arguments".
#656 says Zil she doesn't want to vote phantom like he suggests, asks for his opinion about Nerwen. Even though she was his rep, it would be really weird if wolves were conversing this openly with each other on the thread...
#660 "like I said, I'm slightly uneasy about him though with no arguments to base it on, wouldn't mind seeing him lynched."

Zil about Greenie
Day1: #124 wonders if he should join her in voting Nerwen for a rep.
Day2: #376 replies her points about phantom and Sally.
#409 Greenie is green and doesn't ping his Elfdar, indirectly defends her Sally-vote.
Day3: #564 replies to her points, kind of arguing/explaining.
#606 votes her for rep because: she has already one rep vote, she has been a rep and she's not on tp's "want list" (what's that?) and better than Nerwen since Foley whom he trusts nominated her first. Interesting logic... This starts to look fishy all in all.
#645 mentions her in a stevielysis.
#700 thinks she overreacted to Nerwen's point against her but doesn't think it vote-meriting.
#703 wonders about Rune's sudden suspicion of her and Nerwekeke.
#713 votes Greenie, is the third one to do so. Talk about sudden suspicions...
#715 says Foley is why he voted Green.

Legate

Greenie about Legate
Day1:#69 expands on his point about rep voting the same person.
#76 says he seems reasonable so far.
#95 wonders if he is the Emperor's cat.
Day2: #365 isn't too worried about him because an elf-Legate would be more "polished". This sounds very un-wolf-on-wolfy because it seems like a very genuine notion on his behaviour. Of course there is the possibility, if you want to argue, that Greenie was impressed by her fellow's acting skills and mentions it here, but given I made the very same notion about Legate myself it seems difficult to argue...
#448 "Nog, Steve and Legate are all players I'm inclined to find more innocentish than not but that I'd love to get a better feel of."
#473 replies to his inquiry about lynch preferences.
Day3: #572 says he's leaning innocent for her.
#660 "would be somewhere in my "no idea, maybe leaning innocent" -category, quite honestly I haven't paid that much attention to him."

Legate about Greenie
Day1: #97 is disturbed by her suggestion that he's the Emperor's cat.
#100 calls her reasonable and has her as an option for his rep vote.
#136 mentions her being his rep vote possibility but since other people support electing her too he contemplates leaving her for others to vote Haha sounds like a wolf trying to keep the tallies clean for himself! (Not seriously though, just occured to me and it sounded stupidly funny, or rather, funnily stupid.)
#147 mentions her briefly in his musing about his rep vote.
Day2: #427 mentions her vote while discussing the previous Day's voting but doesn't say much. It's funny how he keeps mentioning the wolves but saying precious little on them...
#470 she seems mostly innocent despite bad vote but won't get his rep vote. For some reason I get innocent vibes from this comment.
Day3: #577 "I had generally good feeling about her, although now that sally's been proven innocent, one could start wondering about her constant case against her."
#662 would like to have a look at her and several others.

Foley

Greenie about Foley
Day1: #76 can't form an opinion on her yet.
#274 inclined to think her innocentish.
Day2: #365 would be really surprised if she was an Elf.
#448 happy that she's a rep and pretty sure she's innocent.
Day3: #572 still thinks her innocent, discusses her behaviour at Day2 voting and says it seems genuine.
#652 whines to her that she still wants to vote Nerwen.

Foley about Greenie
Day1: nothing
Day2: #524 uses her points as a basis of her suspicions of Sally.
Day3: #585 votes her for rep.
#648 tells her it's not a good idea to lynch-vote Nerwen.
#664 asks us not to freak out but she has a very bad feeling about Greenie her rep, got it only after her rep-vote when she started reading more.
#681 announces she's writing a post about her. This would be very cold-hearted wolvish backstabbing...
#687 says she lost her post about her and asks people if they'd like her to rewrite her thoughts.
#698 the promised Greenie-post. Doesn't really reach any conclusion except that Greenie and Rune might be fellows.
#702 Greenie conclusions: if she's an Elf, she's a goo one but Foley doesn't trust her. The lack of good reasons for suspicions is suspicious.

Rune

Greenie about Rune
Day1: #76 more inclined to think him innocent on the little evidence she has.
#274 inclined to think him innocentish.
Day2: #365 gets good vibes from him.
#406 follows his lead when it comes to rep voting and likes him.
#473 thinks him innocent.
Day3: #560 thinks it's ironic his post was innocent except for the part where he considered his own post suspicious.
#572 is very undecided and flip-floppy about him.
#581 replies to Kath considering her read on Rune's ironic post.
#582 considering rep-votes: "I'm debating right now between phantom, Lommy, Rune and Zil."
#583 continues considering rep-votes: "Rune or Inzil for me, then. Both kind of shots in the dark. I'd like to know a bit more about both though."
#584 chooses Zil over Rune because Rune is a tad easier to read.
#652 names him as a lynching option based on her opinion on him being torn and Kath's good points.
#656 still torn about him, but would rather like to see him dead than someone she considers innocent.
#660 "I'm still considering Rune as well, my vote will in all probability go for either him or Nerwen."
#667 torn about voting him or Nerwie.
#669 asks him who he's considering for voting.
#675 decides not to vote him because of her lack of arguments against him.

Rune about Greenie
Day1: #218 says that if he was a rep he'd vote her, Glirdy or Steve. Suspects her for not committing enough.
Day2: #386 doesn't trust her although she seems good, can't put his finger on it.
Day3: #561 replies semi-philosophically to her about stuff being ironic.
#621 wants to look over her and a few others' posts.
#655 doesn't know what to think of her.
#673 replies to her question about his voting preferences, mentions that he has an uneasy feeling about her.
#688 encourages Foley to rewrite her post about Greenie.
#695 she is one of his lynch options but not the primary one.
#710 will vote her to save his own skin.
#712 does that, cross-posting with Nerwen and thus giving the second vote for her.

Kath

Greenie about Kath
Day1: #76 mentions her as someone who hasn't been around yet.
Day2: #365 she's under her radar.
#453 yays her appearance.
Day3: #572 needs more data on her but notes that her long Day2 post looked genuine.
#581 continues on her point about Rune, says it's pity Kath is busy and can't become a rep because of that.
#652 uses her points against Rune.

Kath about Greenie
Day1: nothing
Day2: #460 likes her for asking interesting questions.
#461 she feels innocent to her.
Day3: #578 replies her comments, concludes with: "Good suspicions post, lots of reasoning."
#580 likes her but wants to read her more in-depth (especially about her relation to Wilwa) before rep-voting her.
#643 mentions her in a runelysis.

Eönwë

Greenie about Eönwë
Day1: #76 mentions him as someone who hasn't been around yet.
Day2: #365 has no read on him and says he might need a closer look.
#406 votes him for rep. Again quite from behing the corner. Makes me wonder...
#448 "Nog, Steve and Legate are all players I'm inclined to find more innocentish than not but that I'd love to get a better feel of."
Day3: #572 would love to check his posts and calls him a potential elf for smooth behaviour.
#573 considers him for rep because he hasn't been one yet and making him vote might reveal more of him.
#618 commiserates with him about the difficulty of the game.

Eönwë about Greenie
Day1: #120 considers voting her for rep Huh, that came quite out of the blue...
#137 votes her for rep over Legate because he likes her reasoning and doesn't think she's evil
#267 refers to her earlier point regarding the Lottie-Sally-tp triangle.
Day2: #497 says she seemed innocent yesterDay but not so much toDay. Won't lynch-vote but wants to reread.
Day3: #682 is getting evil undertones from Greenie's recent posts. Talk about rats leaving the stinking ship... (Oops what a typo! Can't resist leaving it uncorrected, though... )

~*~

Conclusions in a separate post, this one is long enough... They are unwritten as of yet though so this will still take a moment...

edit: xed with very many posts

09-24-2010, 03:52 PM	#754
Thinlómien Shady She-Penguin Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: In a far land beyond the Sea Posts: 8,093	Megalysis Okay, decided not to look at Mira's posts myself as Zil quoted them all anyway and I think we've reached a conclusion on her dreams in any case. So off to other work... Omitting our three known innocents... ~~ LOTTIE* *Legate* Legate about Lottie Day1: #45 indirectly says Lottie and Sally's votes might've been out of lack of time, lack of imagination on d1 or SoE bandwagon hiding reasons. #60 worries about Rune's buddying up with people and throws Lottie and Sally to the same category. #68 agrees with Boro's criticism of Lottie and Sally. #100 wouldn't vote her for a rep because of the tp-connection and (relative) absence. #270 mentions her among several others as someone whose lynching he'd consider. Lottie about Legate - nothing - Lommy Lommy about Lottie Day1: #46 does not "heart" Lottie and criticises her "stupid" rep vote. #52 apologises to Sally and Lottie for possible offense. #113 is annoyed by her and other tp-voters but doesn't have any "actual clear reasonable suspicions" against them. #237 Lottie is in her worrisome half of the village. #242 wonders about Lottie's change of mind considering tp and says that if he turns out to be a wolf, we should look at the people who rep-voted him. #247 brings up Lottie's wolfy cheerfulness and voting first and coming up with reasons afterwards and wonders if she should change her mind about her. #254 would like to vote Lottie (and possibly give 1/3 votes to Cel). #264 wonders whether to give Lottie two or three votes. #266 votes her with three votes. The first lynch vote to be given to anyone. Comments: "a bit less of a shot in the dark than most other options". Lottie about Lommy Day1: #306 defends herself against Lommy's points. *Zil* Zil about Lottie Day1: #47 agrees with Lommy's criticism of Lottie and Sally's votes #268 replies to Lommy's question saying he'd like to see one of phantom, Sally or Lottie dead, dislikes phantom's supporting the girls' votes for him. Lottie about Zil Day1: #175 corrects Folwren's misinformation on him #187 explains her nicknames for him and Izzy *Folwren* Lottie about Folwren Day1: #175 corrects her misinformation about Zil. #189 defends tp against her point criticising the two of them and Sally. #196 continues argueing with her to defend tp. Folwren about Lottie Day1: #188 says her and Sally's were not logical or worthwhile and wonders why tp doesn't see this. #193 replies Lottie's defense in a slightly lecturing tone. #239 says the "Sally-and-Lottie-baseless-votes-for-phantom issue" has been discussed enough. True, but it's funny how everything looks so suspicious taken out of context like this... *Eönwë* Eönwë about Lottie Day1: #101 argues against her reasons for voting for tp as a rep. #120 she is among the "other people" he has no idea bout yet. #260 argues against her points again. #267 would be annoyed if she, Sally and tp are all wolves but thinks it's likely there are Elves in the triangle. Lottie about Eönwë #306 counter-criticism against him. Kath and Rune didn't have any interaction with Lottie. Which is quite weird given that she was the hot potato of the Day... ~~ GREENIE* *Lommy* Lommy about Greenie Day1: #113 argues against her points, loves her, likes her and agrees with her but wonders if her vote was even too good, considers her for rep vote. #118 votes Greenie for rep because they are "on the same wavelength". Haha, that sounds bad in the light of the current knowledge, doesn't it? #209 thanks Shasta for taking up her and Greenie's crusade against tp. #217 explains Greenie's internet-problems to the Cave. #237 Greenie is in her not so worrisome half of the village. #266 lets her use the computer. Day2 #419 claims she can read her (and Legate and Rune) well and believes them all innocent. Wouldn't it be funny if Legate and Rune turned out to be wolves too? #452 replies to her questioning her Wilwa comments. #459 repeats claim of being able to read her and thinks her very innocent. Greenie must've been so gleeful reading my posts... Day3 #557 starting to reconsider her previous opinion of Greenie and Legate but still more thinking them innocent. #566 agrees with her about Rune's post being ironic. #590 creeps herself out by half-seriously speculating a phantom-Greenie-Kath pack. #632 answers Nerwen's question about her opinion on Legate and Greenie by: "And no idea about Greenie and Legate. Currently thinking Legate is probably innocent and very unsure about Greenie. " #659 has started to suspect her quite randomly but has a bad feeling her suspicion is wrong, lists her under "difficult" with more than half of the remaining cavers. Speculates about a Shasta+Nerwen+Greenie pack but thinks Greenie+Nerwen unlikely. #663 discusses the lynch options and prefers Shasta. "Zil/Nerwen/Greenie I'm torn about but I would possibly prefer Greenie... not sure at all." Greenie about Lommy Day1: #69 agrees with Lommy's points. #76 says she seems genuine but isn't sure if she wants to vote her for a rep. #79 explains Lommy's point to phantom. #274 inclined to think her innocentish. Day2: #357 delivers her message to the Cave. #365 thinks her very innocent and partly because of her Lottie-vote. #406 hands over the computer to her. #448 asks her how can anyone (Wilwa) be fishy in an innocent way. #462 clarifies Lommy's typo (by request). #471 asks the Cave not to lynch Lommy, tp, Wilwa or Shasta. Day3: #572 can't see her as an Elf, if she's an Elf she deserves to win. #573 considers rep-voting her because she seems innocent. #582 considering rep-votes: "I'm debating right now between phantom, Lommy, Rune and Zil." #583 continues considering rep-votes: "Not Lommy. She, too, has already been a rep, and I don't think that much can be learned from her being one again." #642 mentions her in a nerwielysis. *Zil* Greenie about Zil Day1: #69 agrees with his point of witholding rep votes. #76 can't read him yet but not alarmed. Day2: #365 agonises about never being able to read him. Day3: #572 thinks he's too smooth and can't read him. Anyone else thinking this repetition starts to go quite over the top...? #573 considers him for rep because he hasn't been one yet and making him vote might reveal more of him. #582 considering rep-votes: "I'm debating right now between phantom, Lommy, Rune and Zil." #583 continues considering rep-votes: "Rune or Inzil for me, then. Both kind of shots in the dark. I'd like to know a bit more about both though." #584 rep-votes him. "Because an innocent Inzil can make a good decision on my behalf, and an evil Inzil will hopefully be revealed. " Makes Zil* looks worse than Rune.* #649 asks who Zil wants to lynch. #652 has an uneasy feeling about him but won't vote him because she doesn't have "even half-decent arguments". #656 says Zil she doesn't want to vote phantom like he suggests, asks for his opinion about Nerwen. Even though she was his rep, it would be really weird if wolves were conversing this openly with each other on the thread... #660 "like I said, I'm slightly uneasy about him though with no arguments to base it on, wouldn't mind seeing him lynched." Zil about Greenie Day1: #124 wonders if he should join her in voting Nerwen for a rep. Day2: #376 replies her points about phantom and Sally. #409 Greenie is green and doesn't ping his Elfdar, indirectly defends her Sally-vote. Day3: #564 replies to her points, kind of arguing/explaining. #606 votes her for rep because: she has already one rep vote, she has been a rep and she's not on tp's "want list" (what's that?) and better than Nerwen since Foley whom he trusts nominated her first. Interesting logic... This starts to look fishy all in all. #645 mentions her in a stevielysis. #700 thinks she overreacted to Nerwen's point against her but doesn't think it vote-meriting. #703 wonders about Rune's sudden suspicion of her and Nerwekeke. #713 votes Greenie, is the third one to do so. Talk about sudden suspicions... #715 says Foley is why he voted Green. *Legate* Greenie about Legate Day1:#69 expands on his point about rep voting the same person. #76 says he seems reasonable so far. #95 wonders if he is the Emperor's cat. Day2: #365 isn't too worried about him because an elf-Legate would be more "polished". This sounds very un-wolf-on-wolfy because it seems like a very genuine notion on his behaviour. Of course there is the possibility, if you want to argue, that Greenie was impressed by her fellow's acting skills and mentions it here, but given I made the very same notion about Legate myself it seems difficult to argue... #448 "Nog, Steve and Legate are all players I'm inclined to find more innocentish than not but that I'd love to get a better feel of." #473 replies to his inquiry about lynch preferences. Day3: #572 says he's leaning innocent for her. #660 "would be somewhere in my "no idea, maybe leaning innocent" -category, quite honestly I haven't paid that much attention to him." Legate about Greenie Day1: #97 is disturbed by her suggestion that he's the Emperor's cat. #100 calls her reasonable and has her as an option for his rep vote. #136 mentions her being his rep vote possibility but since other people support electing her too he contemplates leaving her for others to vote Haha sounds like a wolf trying to keep the tallies clean for himself! (Not seriously though, just occured to me and it sounded stupidly funny, or rather, funnily stupid.) #147 mentions her briefly in his musing about his rep vote. Day2: #427 mentions her vote while discussing the previous Day's voting but doesn't say much. It's funny how he keeps mentioning the wolves but saying precious little on them... #470 she seems mostly innocent despite bad vote but won't get his rep vote. For some reason I get innocent vibes from this comment. Day3: #577 "I had generally good feeling about her, although now that sally's been proven innocent, one could start wondering about her constant case against her." #662 would like to have a look at her and several others. *Foley* Greenie about Foley Day1: #76 can't form an opinion on her yet. #274 inclined to think her innocentish. Day2: #365 would be really surprised if she was an Elf. #448 happy that she's a rep and pretty sure she's innocent. Day3: #572 still thinks her innocent, discusses her behaviour at Day2 voting and says it seems genuine. #652 whines to her that she still wants to vote Nerwen. Foley about Greenie Day1: nothing Day2: #524 uses her points as a basis of her suspicions of Sally. Day3: #585 votes her for rep. #648 tells her it's not a good idea to lynch-vote Nerwen. #664 asks us not to freak out but she has a very bad feeling about Greenie her rep, got it only after her rep-vote when she started reading more. #681 announces she's writing a post about her. This would be very cold-hearted wolvish backstabbing... #687 says she lost her post about her and asks people if they'd like her to rewrite her thoughts. #698 the promised Greenie-post. Doesn't really reach any conclusion except that Greenie and Rune might be fellows. #702 Greenie conclusions: if she's an Elf, she's a goo one but Foley doesn't trust her. The lack of good reasons for suspicions is suspicious. *Rune* Greenie about Rune Day1: #76 more inclined to think him innocent on the little evidence she has. #274 inclined to think him innocentish. Day2: #365 gets good vibes from him. #406 follows his lead when it comes to rep voting and likes him. #473 thinks him innocent. Day3: #560 thinks it's ironic his post was innocent except for the part where he considered his own post suspicious. #572 is very undecided and flip-floppy about him. #581 replies to Kath considering her read on Rune's ironic post. #582 considering rep-votes: "I'm debating right now between phantom, Lommy, Rune and Zil." #583 continues considering rep-votes: "Rune or Inzil for me, then. Both kind of shots in the dark. I'd like to know a bit more about both though." #584 chooses Zil over Rune because Rune is a tad easier to read. #652 names him as a lynching option based on her opinion on him being torn and Kath's good points. #656 still torn about him, but would rather like to see him dead than someone she considers innocent. #660 "I'm still considering Rune as well, my vote will in all probability go for either him or Nerwen." #667 torn about voting him or Nerwie. #669 asks him who he's considering for voting. #675 decides not to vote him because of her lack of arguments against him. Rune about Greenie Day1: #218 says that if he was a rep he'd vote her, Glirdy or Steve. Suspects her for not committing enough. Day2: #386 doesn't trust her although she seems good, can't put his finger on it. Day3: #561 replies semi-philosophically to her about stuff being ironic. #621 wants to look over her and a few others' posts. #655 doesn't know what to think of her. #673 replies to her question about his voting preferences, mentions that he has an uneasy feeling about her. #688 encourages Foley to rewrite her post about Greenie. #695 she is one of his lynch options but not the primary one. #710 will vote her to save his own skin. #712 does that, cross-posting with Nerwen and thus giving the second vote for her. *Kath* Greenie about Kath Day1: #76 mentions her as someone who hasn't been around yet. Day2: #365 she's under her radar. #453 yays her appearance. Day3: #572 needs more data on her but notes that her long Day2 post looked genuine. #581 continues on her point about Rune, says it's pity Kath is busy and can't become a rep because of that. #652 uses her points against Rune. Kath about Greenie Day1: nothing Day2: #460 likes her for asking interesting questions. #461 she feels innocent to her. Day3: #578 replies her comments, concludes with: "Good suspicions post, lots of reasoning." #580 likes her but wants to read her more in-depth (especially about her relation to Wilwa) before rep-voting her. #643 mentions her in a runelysis. *Eönwë* Greenie about Eönwë Day1: #76 mentions him as someone who hasn't been around yet. Day2: #365 has no read on him and says he might need a closer look. #406 votes him for rep. Again quite from behing the corner. Makes me wonder... #448 "Nog, Steve and Legate are all players I'm inclined to find more innocentish than not but that I'd love to get a better feel of." Day3: #572 would love to check his posts and calls him a potential elf for smooth behaviour. #573 considers him for rep because he hasn't been one yet and making him vote might reveal more of him. #618 commiserates with him about the difficulty of the game. Eönwë about Greenie Day1: #120 considers voting her for rep Huh, that came quite out of the blue... #137 votes her for rep over Legate because he likes her reasoning and doesn't think she's evil #267 refers to her earlier point regarding the Lottie-Sally-tp triangle. Day2: #497 says she seemed innocent yesterDay but not so much toDay. Won't lynch-vote but wants to reread. Day3: #682 is getting evil undertones from Greenie's recent posts. Talk about rats leaving the stinking ship... (Oops what a typo! Can't resist leaving it uncorrected, though... ) ~~ Conclusions in a separate post, this one is long enough... They are unwritten as of yet though so this will still take a moment... edit: xed with very many posts __________________ Like the stars chase the sun, over the glowing hill I will conquer Blood is running deep, some things never sleep Double Fenris*