Quote:
Originally Posted by Thinlómien
Now this makes me actually think whether the hunter should come out and we should lynch him/her and s/he could have a shot at a wolf and we could have another hunter and thus get the advantage of having the heir on our side as the new hunter.
|
I actually think that's a good idea. I've always been of the opinion that protecting the Hunter is pointless, and that the Hunter should want to die (it's the whole point of their role afterall). So they come forward, we lynch them, maybe get lucky and they bring a wolf down with them, then the Heir becomes the new Hunter. Hunter fulfills their purpose and the Heir is on our side, it's a good situation. Otherwise if we lynch a wolf today than they get replaced, and it's just a waste of a Day. BUT, one bad case scenario is if we do the Hunter thing and then the wolves get the Seer tonight, then we won't have the Heir to take over that role anymore. Or if the Hunter is unlucky enough to take the Ranger or Seer down with them. Hmm....there are too many scenarios here.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Greenie
Basically, we don't want to kill a wolf until we have killed a Gifted, right?
|
Uhm...yes? It makes this game sound so nuts. "We don't want to lynch a Wolf! We want to lynch our Hunter!" We've all lost out minds...
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Inzil
And here's a question: say the Hunter takes a Gifted or a wolf with xem. Who does the Heir replace, the actual first one dead, which would be the Hunter?
|
I was wondering the same, but I'm going to venture that it would be the Hunter, since that is the one that we are actively killing.
edit: x'ed with Eomer (interesting idea, especially good one if the Seer has already managed to get a wolf) and Inzil (that's possible, if two of them don't really like the third, or if one simply starts to attract too much attention, they may back stab them knowing that they would just be getting someone else to replace them, and then they are free to kill the Gifteds without any worries, and they look good to the village for having voted a wolf)