I approve of
Nog and
phantom advising the gifteds - at least in the sense that it's typical of them. Yeah the gifteds are usually capable of thinking things through themselves, but saying something just to be on the safe side shouldn't hurt anyone.
At the moment some people seem to be (considering) voting for a quiet player. Is that a good idea? I'd actually rather leave the quieter players alive this time... The more they post, the more trails we have.
Quote:
Originally Posted by the phantom
if you have an inkling of who the Seer might possibly be and that person dies, you should go ahead and point out your theory (especially if you can discover some sort of coded message or whatnot, I'm not the only person who does that sort of thing, am I?) and then treat future Dead-votes as a vindication of someone, assuming that the Seer is able to properly convince the Dead upon arrival.
|
That sounds reasonable, I guess (and hehe no you aren't
)... But even a few baddies can screw up the voting in Mandos, so we really have no way of being sure. That's the problem with just about every plan. We can of course risk it and agree on a plan of sorts, especially if the lovers and/or Glorfindel is still alive, but I'm skeptical.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin
Excuse me?!
Sorry, still reading, but that caught my eye and now I'm going to have to challenge Manwe to a duel.
|
I was looking forward to seeing your reaction.
Quote:
Originally Posted by A Little Green
Hey! You of all people don't get to call me nit-picky!
|
Yes I do. You always find me unclear and ask for a clarification.