Quote:
Originally Posted by the phantom
False! As I said before, given this set up there is no purpose whatsoever to the Lovers hinting at one another. They already know each other, and it's extremely easy to prove their truthfulness (they COME BACK TO LIFE).
A Lover has no need to bluff or double-bluff, or hint or anything at all. A Lover in this game is simply an Ordo who rises from the grave, and is thus a PROVEN innocent. To say that Shasta was attempting any sort of Lover-based bluff I think is to misjudge his grasp of his role. (i.e. If I were a Wolf I wouldn't bother in the least trying to look for a Lover other than just looking for general jumpiness perhaps that might speak of a Gifted.)
|
Yeah, but...
Shasta actually
did go out of his way to joke about being
Lúthien. So whether it made sense for him to try a double-bluff or not, it seems that's what he did. (I'm assuming
Agan's telling the truth.)
So–
was that what put the wolves on his trail? After all, nobody seemed to take it seriously at the time. And would that mean our wolves are showing great subtlety– or none whatever? (
"Duuuh... well, he said
he's Lúthien...")
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Speaking of which... I have noticed some of you guys speak of people peeking at the dead-thread prematurely is more or less understandable and kind of obvious people do it (tp even admitted doing that, which actually fits well with my thought of him being the cobbler). And looking at the number of views there (182) thus far strongly suggests it's not done only by the mods and now two players, added with random 'Downers just curious what the thread is about.
So let me strongly disagree and protest.
Keep away from it. Really.
Looking there is unsportsmanlike and bad gaming. And what's the joy of winning if you gain it by deceit?
|
Quite right– and all I can say is, whoever's been looking at the thread, it isn't me.
EDIT:X'd with many.