A quick look at
Elra. DOES NOT include full quotes of all her posts, only the extracts I thought were or could be relevant.
Day 1
Quote:
Anyhow. Most unhappy with not having a very good read on anybody yet.
Legate, Nog, and Agan are of course posting their usual tomes. Lommy seems a little more...confused...than usual. (Though who am I to talk about "usual", this being only my third game ever...) phantom is on my good side at the moment. Despite the incessant chatter (joke), he seems to be thinking things through in a more, erm, down-to-earth fashion than other tome-writers (sorry, Legate and Co.).
|
So
Lommy is confused an
phantom looks good.
Quote:
This is the way my brain is working too... The train of thought goes: "Okay, we want to kill the baddies. But we also don't want to make malicious ghosts. Crap."
This tension between Nogrod and Shasta worries me somewhat. Hrmmm.
|
Quote:
++Nogrod
Partly because Shasta's overreaction makes him seem innocent. And if Nog's not guilty, then he'll be a helpful ghost.
|
So, the tension between
Shasta and
Nog is worrying,
Shasta's reaction looks innocent, so she votes for
Nog. I'm not sure of the soundness of this logic (given how wrong innocents can be of each other), but for Day 1 it looks fair enough.
Day 2
Quote:
Oh dear, oh dear. Poor Shasta.
I still don't know quite what to make of yesterDay. Manwe's been killed, for reasons beyond me. That whole Shasta vs. Nog thing was troublesome, and probably why Shasta got dead. Makes me worry about Nog. And phantom is a bother at the back of my brain. Something seems off about him, despite his sense-making. Or maybe that's just him. So many people in this game that I haven't played with before...this makes for an uncomfortable lack of predictability.
|
The first line looks fabricated, but then, I think that
every time someone expresses misery over a Night kill. I'm not a fan of the tone of the second paragraph either, but can't really pinpoint what exactly is off there.
Quote:
|
Dear me. I don't like any of this at all. Nog, the seer?!? What? Gah. He could very well be being truthsome, and tp etc. ganging up on him to distract. Or he could be trying to fool us all into going after tp, which people will undoubtedly be willing to do, considering phanty's verbosity. I simply don't know which faction is right. Both of them have been pinging my "uh-oh" radar. I may abstain today if this goes on much longer.
|
Looks like honest confusion, but I don't know how much can be read to that - after all, there's no reason why that situation would have been any less confusing to a wolf (unless either
Nog or
phantom is one, of course).
Quote:
|
Abstaining. At this point om not going to change the outcome, and I don't think I can condone either side. Sorry, all.
|
Day 3
Only one post this far.
Quote:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Boro
As far as this, I should clear up that I'm in no way interested in voting for the phantom today or even if we did find out about Nog's role. That's outloud thinking that simply because Fea died and Nog looked evil, doesn't mean phantom looks better, or I'm not understanding how he looks better.
|
I agree with you on this. phantom still seems fishy, but not to the point of being wolfish. There are much better targets to be examined than him.
|
What caught my eye about
Elra's posts is how her opinion on
the phantom changes. Day 1 he feels good, Day 2 he seems off and has been pinging her "uh-oh" -radar, and Day 3 he still seems fishy but there are better candidates. Generally
Elra's leaning more innocent than not. Her first post on Day 2 is slightly fishy, but other than that I caught nothing that would point to evil intentions.