My vote the previous day would have been either for
phantom or
Lottie. And if I was on to see the situation, then would have voted Lottie, for whatever that's worse. It wouldn't have changed the outcome.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anguirel
and one other matter. How near are we, statistically, to defeat? Could someone better at counting than I am (seriously, I study poetry, I dropped maths at fifteen, I am mentally and verbally innumerate) help me out here? If there are two wolves, does one failed lynch and one kill finish us? let me see. 2 from 8 = 6. Now if there are three - yeah. If there are three we're seriously close to the wall now, especially as there's probably still a cobbler around, even if I'm pretty sure his name is phantom
|
With
Legate being a known cobbler, doesn't it seem like we've already killed 5 cobblers so far?
Obviously that's not possible, and it's feasible that all those turning up not-wolves, are indeed not cobblers. But taking out
Legate, there's two left and it's entirely plausible one of the known not-wolves in the dead thread is cobblery.
I guess my point is, at this stage in the game, we have to go for straight up tricky and false behavior. If the person's a cobbler, and we lose, so be it. But we can't have 5-6 cobblers running around here, so there's got to be wolves in this forsaken place somewhere.
My jump on phantom boils down to I think that was an orchestrated double-lynch be
phantom and
Lottie.
Lottie we know, follows around
phantom like a puppy, and having played wolves with her before, she will take a bullet for a packmate. Phantom could have easily set that play up at night, by cherry-picking
Lommy (which I admit I fell for because I thought her behavior was being completely ridiculous) while
Lottie (or another packmate) go after Nessa.
And now that I'm on this subject, don't you find that business between
Nog and
phantom a bit too clean?
Nog sets the noose around his own neck, and
phantom starts proclaiming he knew what
Nog was going to do, after the previous day defending
Nog.
Add on top of that,
phantom's plans and his post on Glorfindel's reveal, I truly and completely disagreed with. It was far too early to ask Glorfindel to reveal his/her info. And to argue that he wanted Glorfindel out and then to force the wolf pack into believing they had to kill him is ridiculous. Even though this was only yesterday, with basically what amounts to a triple-lynch during the night, if
Glorfy's alive, looking at the desperate situation and need for some type of tangible roles...now is as good of a time as any for Glorfy to step out.
However, no one needs to go on their high horse and start vehemently demanding it.
*Remembers what wolf-Nog and cobbler-me did to poor Wilwa-Ranger in a not so distant past.*