Just a side note:
If "God" creates the world and all creatures in it so that the creatures can
use their mind and free will, he has to give them an opportunity to make choices. If there is only good, there is no choice. If creatures cannot make their own decisions, what is the use of free will and mind? And if there's no mind or free will, it's as if the creatures are lumps of stone that cannot do anything on its own (hehe, like Aule's stone dwarves and what Eru said about them). It's like a puppet show. Doesn't the world lose all its beauty that way?
You need evil to create a
difference, a
choice.
Just imagined a really weird thing: this "God" sitting up there watching us discuss him and compare him to Eru!
