Quote:
Originally Posted by Mithalwen
Surely the elves are feudal rather than communist. Mirkwood and Lorien are ruled by lords who are or are the descendants of colonists of "superior" races. Imladris is Elrond's own household. The clothing and food he provides to the company seems a personal gift. He himself is not an elected figure but the heir of the High Kings of the Noldor. Cirdan may have earned his authority as lord of the residual community at Mithlond but that was surely a very small community serving a specific purpose.
We know in Mirkwood some things are reserved for the King and court, they trade. It may be benevolent but it is still feudal.
|
Basically all the nations in M-E are effectively "feudal" in the sense, they have a King or something like that. However, I agree with that idea that I imagine Elvish society as effectively communist - as much as it can be, in the purest sense (not even socialism, but pure communism). Human societies are more or less feudal, even as for the relationships between people, division of labor etc. But I don't imagine Elves having much of that. What do they do? They sing, wander the woods, weave cloaks and forge swords, but there is never a hint of that somebody would pay to somebody XY for a cloak or for a sword. And except for a particular few things like "Turgon's sword", "Maedhros' harp", "Galadriel's Ring" or such stuff (and the unfortunate Silmarils, but these are really a special case), I don't see very much of personal claims of private property of anything either. Yes, the
form is, let's say, monarchy - you have a King and you have people with certain political status, but when it comes to property and the production relations - then I believe we are looking at something closest to communism.
I really imagine it as a "freely create, freely give" society. Some Elves bake all the delicacies for Elrond's parties. Some just sing. Others are reforging Andúril meanwhile. But there is no whatsoever concept of "I will give you two pieces of bread for one Andúril", I am imagining it the way that on a common day in Rivendell, you just come to the table and take some lembas and wine simply because there is enough of it. You, on the other hand, do something else for the Elves, let's say, make a nice statue in front of the house. But you don't have to, but even though (or maybe because) you don't have to, you still do it: and the Elves do it simply of their own good will - it's not an obligation. Once again, very utopistic, but obviously working with the Elves. I honestly cannot imagine Elves having any sort of trade relationships among themselves: at most between different cities etc., in the sense "we give you marble from Gondolin and you give us six thousand spears". But then once again, the smiths in city B just take it as their personal duty to forge six thousand spearheads, and they somehow manage it so that it can be sent to Gondolin. And, needless to note, I don't expect that the smiths are "paid" by anyone or anything - and that is the most important part, I believe.
So once again: the form may be "feudal", having a king, but the way the society of the Elves works, I really believe "communism" might be rather a close term, of all those we have.