Quote:
Originally Posted by Bęthberry
The text that we have as The Silm is a highly edited text, and it is put together by a scholar whose intent was to provide some kind of comprehensive format of a very long process. While CT followed his father's intent, it is very possible that that scholarly overview was very different from how a creative writer would have combined the disparate and changing stories. JRRT wrote according to his notions and ideas of what makes a good story. CT edited with notions of how to make a consistent redaction. Those two aims produce very different styles.
|
This almost makes me wonder if a 'good parts' version of the
Silmarillion ought to be written. Spider Robinson wrote a posthumous Heinlein novel,
Variable Star, based on Heinlein's outline and notes from 1955. We have a scholarly presentation version of
Silmarillion. Is there a modern writer anyone would trust to turn it into fiction?