[Nerwen]

Originally Posted by ZIl

Ah, good to hear. Just watch out for the koalas. I hear they have five-inch teeth and acid for blood.

Yes, but they mostly keep to the trees. It's the man-eating kangaroos that are the real hazard.

Originally Posted by Inzil

I don't see what makes either of them particularly innocent. I haven't seen much of Fea. And I can't go along with what Nog said about her subbing for the mysterious Laura being a sign of her likely innocence. That shouldn't be a factor.

Yes– what is with people in this game just declaring other people to be innocent? They can't be preparing for reveals (false or otherwise), and it doesn't really make sense as hinting either, so what is it?

Originally Posted by Wilwa

There's another possibility. Maybe Sam did choose Lhuna, but Lhuna wasn't the target; Sam was. In that case knowing Same chose Lhuna would really not mean much at all, Lhuna could have still been the one stung the day before, or she could be Shelob.

Originally Posted by Wilwa

If I was Sam I probably would have chosen Lhuna, because a lot of people seemed to think that was a good idea, and I think a lot of people will say they would have chosen Lhuna if they were Sam (which makes me think Shelob did not sting Lhuna, knowing Sam had probably chosen her; therefore Shelob's target was likely Sam himself). So if Sam was the target, then knowing who his chose was isn't really important. That's why to me the whole exercise doesn't seem overly productive.

As I understand it, Sam has had a shot at both healing someone and at protecting someone– not necessarily the same person– in fact probably not. (If I'm wrong about this, could our moddess please clarify?) We know the protection was successful, unless as you say the target was Sam himself. I've been assuming the cure was unsuccessful, or Sally would have said something about it. Though now I think about it, she didn't say, "the stung has been turned", either.

Anyway, I wouldn't be so sure Sam followed phantom's orders. For all you know he might have found the way he was pushing for Lhuna alarming.