[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Galadriel55

I remember Legate saying that he intends to vote Lottie. You were less suspicious about her, but you said at some point that you have a bad gut-feeling about her and Eomer.

I think he was unsure between Sally and Lottie?

Anyway, a list:

Bom Tombadillo - mm no idea, especially as he has disappeared. More evidence please! I don't think his jump on Sally was necessarily evil, more like careless/weird thinking.

Nogrod - I like him this far. He makes sense in a way that makes me confortable, but also says weird stuff enough that I don't worry about him being a smooth super manipulative wolf guru. Also, his vote nailed Lottie's coffin, which also might be a point in his favour.

Kitanna- I'm trying not to suspect her, because I always suspect her and because I don't want to be knee-jerky AND because everyone else suspects her and I'd rather not add my voice to that choir with this little evidence, but she is a little suspicious. The thing that worries me the most is how her analyses/posts seem like they aim at pointing out suspicious behaviour, not at catching wolves. It's a subtle difference but it might be there.

G55 - I'm quite impressed by her very un-newbieish playing style! Other than that, I don't really have much opinion, except that she doesn't strike me as overtly defensive like Legate said.

Sally - nothing new: she tends not to proclaim her innocence when she's evil, but otherwise I cannot judge her.

Eomer - very interesting. He has apparently taken a gallant knight tactic, rushing to defend other players wherever he sees a misunderstanding or a faulty accusation (to exaggerate a bit). I'm not sure what to make of it (if it's wolvish buddying up or genuine innocent helpfulness), but at least my gut-feeling of him is better toDay than yesterDay.

Nerwen - arg, slipping under my radar. No idea. Should pay more attention to her or she wll do the typical wolf-Nerwen win.

Greenie - hasn't been around enough to judge properly. Wasn't too suspicious yesterDay anyhow.

Nilp - I'm trying to avoid thinking him innocent just 'cos he thinks I'm innocent, but I seriously cannot see anything off with this guy for now. Of course, he's known to pull impressive innocent face stunts before, so maybe I shouldn't be sure.

Mithalwen - other than having great wolvish insights, not much to say about her. Doesn't strike me as too bad or too good, and I agree with whoever (Kit?) said her concentration on the rules makes her difficult to read.

Legate - on the other hand, he seems very genuine, on the other, his smooth manner reminds me of the evil genius Legate. I think he is actually rather under my radar. Leaning innocent anyhow.

...and where are the wolves in this list of unsures and innocents? Dunno. If I had to bet, I'd say Kit and Mith, or maybe Kit and Nerwen. No idea though (happily there's still plenty of time 'til DL but I'll be away for the next few hours).