Now after all that writing, I can finally take a breath and decide what to think of
Nog.
To add to the things above, he only "noticed"
Lottie's "slip" after
Shasta's analysis. And he was the last one to vote
Lottie.
Despite that, he does not give me a bad gut-feeling, and at most of the time is quite reasonable.
Edit: xed with
Nog. You're not the only one with a computer like that! (mine ate an extremely long post yesterday...)