Oh, for the love of cupcakes. I finally read (most of) the thread in its entirety, and am dying of laughter. This has been truly inconceivable, and I've missed most of it!
Things I know:
Nerwen: wolf
Shasta: wolf
Eomer: seer
Bom: ranger
Boro: hunter
Sally: ordo
Things I think:
Eruhen: new kid, leaning innocent
Tum: quick to validate my absence, which could be either innocent or an attempt at camaraderie with an innocent so I don't suspect her
Foley: misguided, possible wolf by virtue of making a ridiculous case, but likely not
Steve: possible wolf (lack of vibes)
Galadriel: possibly innocent, although I still have a definite niggle of suspicion
Gah. That didn't really help me much. I'll have to look a bit closer when I have time later on. However, at the moment, my top suspects are Steve and Galadriel.
Or, you know, Nerwen could just cave and tell us. That would be lovely.