So, how did everybody treat
Nog on Day2? For Day1, please see
this post.
Lommy defends
Nog’s change of heart concerning
Gal (#165). Lists
Nog under “innocentish” and says she has good gut-feeling about
Nog and trusts him for the time being (#204). [Editor's note: after reading the posts she xed with] amends that
Nog looks a little worse (#206). Believes the revelation and votes
Nog (#273).
Legate [my analysis was almost done in the end of yesterDay, so he was included all along, and I will leave this here in case it's of scientific interest to anyone] slightly defends Nog’s Legate-180 on Gal (#166, a cross-post with Lommy’s #165). Then he defends/explains Nog’s anger ventilation to Pom (#178). The discussion continues (#182). Then he discusses Rikae with him (#190). Makes fun of him and tells him to read his (Legate’s) post (#191). Attacks Eönwë for a suspicious attack on Nog (#194). Lists Nog under “grey” (his second most innocent category) and says a lot about him seems innocentish but there have also been good points against him lately (#213). As has been discussed, doesn’t believe Steve’s reveal (#236). Continues this (#239). Then, more or less makes a Legate-180 (#248). Ponders about lynching Zil in Nog's stead or making a double lynch, but concludes single lynch is much better (#275). Votes him not to split the votes (#276). Agrees with Pitch's arguments for Steve and against Nog (#276).
Pom points out
Nog’s major role in the
Bom-lynch but doesn’t conclude much from it (#167). She further discusses
Bom-wagon, mentioning
Nog several times (#172). She defends to
Nog why emphasising his role in the
Bom-lynch made sense (#173). Argues with
Legate about
Nog’s innocence/sensibility (#180). Thinks he answered her suspicions pretty well (#231). She leaves before
Eönwë's reveal.
Pitch criticises the
Bom-lynch and directs the criticism towards
Nog (#168). He answers his criticism (#175). Rants a little more about the
Bom-lynch, says
Steve’s attack on
Nog makes him look better despite his (
Pitch’s) earlier suspicions on him (
Nog) and discusses
Rikae’s death with
Nog (#211). A rather aggressive point against him (#214). Again, discusses
Rikae with him (#224). After the reveal, he trusts
Steve (and shortly tells why) and votes
Nog (#277).
Boro discusses
Rikae’s death with
Nog, and defends himself (#177). He defends
Eönwë’s attack on
Nog and discusses
Nog’s actions in the
Bom-wagon without labelling them as anything else than “overkill”, as opposed to “suspicious” or “innocentish”, but says he seems to be treading carefully which implies suspicion (#203). He crosses with the seer reveal while saying:
Nog was careful yesterDay but maybe an inncent
Nog would have a reason to do that too, says he wanted to refrain from commenting (and encourage others to do so too)
Eönwë's attack on
Nog before
Nog himself reacts, he has conflicting opinions about
Nog himself (sometimes he sounds genuine, sometimes he sounds really bad) and is not sure whether everything thus far is enough for him to vote him as he recalls innocent
Nog often being paranoid too (#254). He is amused by
Nog's desperation and faulty facts and votes him (#267).
Lottie trusts
Steve's reveal and votes
Nog (#256).
Sally is catching up: she finds
Nog willingness to help
Bom's suicide alarming and after reading until the end of page five, she lists
Nog in her guilty category which covers half of the village (#265). Votes
Nog but mentions the possibilty
Steve is lying (#266).
Shasta trusts
Steve and believes in
Nog's guilt, but believes we should lynch
Zil the assumed acolyte (#268).
Greenie says that regardless of
Nog's starting it,
Shasta was the one behind the
Bom-lynch (#184). She acknowledges and adds points against
Nog but says she has a good gut-feeling about him (#187). She doesn't like
Eönwë's jump on
Nog and agrees with
Legate's points about it (#195) then votes
Eönwë (#196). She leaves before
Eönwë's reveal.
Conclusions to follow.