Shasta - still toiling through the snow, it seems.
Menel - oy vey. Why so concentrated on proving a truth that already has been proven, when he is questioned based on why he posts it rather the content itself?
Menel concentrated on this one issue, though he didn't actually comment directly on it, without participating in others. I can't say that an obsession with proving the obvious truth is signalling a wolf, though, and since there's hardly aught else there's not much to go on. I suppose I'll accept what others have said about this being his playing style (since they would know better than me) and letting it go for toDay.
Glirdan - still reading.
G55 - *waves*
Nerwen - hard to tell, which is nothing new.
Legate - makes me alert, but no red light yet. Can't really say where the ill-at-ease feeling is comming from.
Pitchwife - I think he is overly suspicious of
Kath's question about the cobbler pick going through. Or, rather, he gives me the vibe that he's expectant of people to side with him, even wanting people to side with him (Mostly referring to #21). However, his vote for
Nog is not unreasonable from his perspective.
Nogrod - doesn't look too out-of-character. Says what he would normally say. Except... see note on bottom.
Lommy – sick, therefore excused. I love her for saying that I "mess around" on Day Ones, cause that's what usually ends up happening. Objectively speaking, she looks ok.
Inzil - seems like the same innocent
Inzil I've seen in previous games.
Agan - is
Agan *sigh*. She's a cobbler whatever her actual role.
Sally - full of migrane, therefore excused.
Kath - Despite the suspicion, I rather like that she brought up the cobbler, since it gave people something to discuss. And the questions she asks (eg about the narration) are something an innocent could ask just as much as a wolf, so in my opinion they don't show any particular wolvishness.
NOTE:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Now where is your commitment with 40 posts on D1? Or anyone elses'?  |
This is the one thing about
Nog that bothers me, but it's so trivial it's bound to be ridiculous. Somehow, I can't imagine
Nog saying that with a "
" on his face. I'd expect his expression to be more like "
". Was he trying to "be nice" to avoid
Pitchie's oncoming vote?
Blargh, this is worse that the "she-cobbler" case. I can't build proper cases on Day1. ><
EDIT: xed since my last.
Shasta's here!!!