Quote:
Originally Posted by Galadriel55
Well, I have to go to bed soon, otherwise my head will feel like a brick tomorrow. Looking at my list, Pitch is the one who gives me the most bad vibes. See the list for my thoughts on him.
++PITCH
Incidentally, what was the decision for ties? I don't think this point was ever clarified...
|
Ehhh. I don't like this at all.
G55's first suspicion was on
Menel, and it was bandwagony. In her list, though, she backs off
Menel (because of the opposition it's getting?) and really only gives a solid statement on
Pitch (and perhaps [b]Nogrod, but as it's based on an emoticon...) while also saying this -
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by G55
However, his vote for Nog is not unreasonable from his perspective.
|
- which is extremely confusing; if you don't agree with
Pitch's perspective (hence being suspicious of him on your list), how can his vote be okay?
Summa summarum -
G55 suspects
Menel until opposition is too strong, and backs off, going instead for
Pitch with odd/weird/confusing reasoning. I don't disagree that
Pitch is suspicious (cf. my previous post - he does seem like he's jumping at the chance to blow up incredibly minor things into full-fledged suspicion), but I think I'm more suspicious of
G55.
++G55