Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerwen
Agan at #198 makes an excellent analysis of The Sinister Sally, bringisg out some points I don't think anyone else had. Then she winds up with a quite invalid suspicion, based on out-of-context quoting.
|
Are you talking about the one you quoted earlier? What bugged me about it was that
sally seemed to be downplaying the importance of lynching a wolf today - although granted, the situation wasn't as serious as
Nog made it seem.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shastanis Althreduin
Given how doom and gloom he was, he looks like an innocent who's just given up - but then there's the whole "what if he was just doing that on purpose to make me think that?" argument. I don't think I really want to draw any conclusions from that, specifically.
|
Me neither.
Quote:
|
It's actually one, provided the wolves pile on their votes first. That's rather more scary, I think.
|
True. However, it would require every wolf to be here at the same time, otherwise it might go wrong. And there's still the ranger.
Anyway, so far (I think) only
Legate and
Kath have voted. I hope either
Nog or one of them is a wolf... But then, the wolves can't afford to make any too risky moves yet because the situation will soon turn against them if the ranger makes a save.
Quote:
|
Re: Lommy. If that's so, though, why follow Agan's vote?
|
Ditto to that.
Quote:
|
A lot of what you're saying makes sense to me, Agan, but this quote looks to me like Sally's is asking for thoughts about lynching the cobbler - which, indeed, is something we could have done about them.
|
Nope - we could've lynched the cobbler, but we couldn't have known it before he was dead. She's talking about
finding the cobbler. We can't find the cobbler. Do you see what I mean?
I have to leave very soon and I won't be back before deadline. I'd prefer to lynch
sally or
Legate. Is there anyone around?
edit: apparently at least
Nerwen.
