Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nerwen
I know– but what would a Wolflote have to gain by making up a story like that, though? When she could just fake-reveal?
|
Hmmm... Yeah, it's tough to consider the angles here, as there's really no precedent.
Okay- pretend for a moment that
Lottie is telling the truth. That means Elendil is still alive and knows precisely who a dream target was. We're getting down to the wire here so it's also possible both Elendil and the other Gifted might reveal, which would narrow the potential lynch field by a LOT, particularly with the Amandil info-holder removing himself from consideration.
So- I think what that means is that
Lottie may be forced to tell the truth about her dream even if she's a KM, if you follow me. For if she lies, then it would rule out both her AND her dream as a KM, thus reducing the potential KMs in the village to 2 when in fact there are 3 still alive.
Thus KM-
Lottie's only hope of survival would be to sell out her packmate and hope that when the final day arrives she is given the benefit of the doubt versus whoever the other candidate is.
Does that make sense?
In other words, I'm saying even if we choose to believe
Lottie we aren't necessarily agreeing that she's innocent. I just feel that it's important to keep this in perspective.