Quote:
|
Nope Elrond had greater knowledge about the lore of the past and greater foresight of the future.
|
What, Elrond has greater knowlege about the past than Galadriel who actually experianced that??!! And who was a match for the loremaster in Valinor, so that would include Rumil
Quote:
|
An Elven loremaster, the inventor of written letters. His invention was later bettered by Fëanor, but Rúmil remains famous as the originator of writing.
|
And could look more into the future like Galadriel, who is said to be able to look in the future via her mirror? Forsight is kinda different than looking into the future.
Quote:
|
I have shown and given countless quotes showing Elrond was not one of the Eldar, but one of the Half-elven.
|
He chose to be counted among the Eldar and is included if Tolkien talks about elves. Even Arwen was acounted as Eldar, i.e. third marriege between the Eldar and Edain. He had to chose for one and all, beacuse there should be no in-between race, that however doesnīt change what he is genetically.Whereīs the problem? He belongs to the elves, Arwen belongs to men, Elros belogs to men, Tuor belongs to the elves, more be precise to the Noldor.
Really, I donīt understand! Galadriel + Feanor = equal (according to Tolkien) and greatest of the Noldor (whatever greatness means) So how can Elrond be more powerful than Galadriel if Galadriel was equal in might to Feanor.
Quote:
|
Going against the Valar's wishes is not a good thing. Elrond was the one, who constantly argued against Saruman's council. Where and when?
|
Ah OK, even if Galadriel know for sure that she was doing the right thing, because Saruman was not trustworthy, she shouldnīt do it because itīs against the valar wishes. If that is true, why had she got a brain?
Itīs hopeless.