Brinniel, the only clever troll among us...
Day 1
#63 - votes
Nerwen.
- feels good about
Rikae
- doesn't like my vote
- lets
Morsul's
Kath suspicion go for now
- doesn't like
Sally's banter, "but then again it is Sally".
- reasoning for
Nerwen vote is "While I don't feel terribly confident in my vote, she has displayed the most suspicious behavior to me so far."
Based on that, she might have dreamed of
Rikae on Night 1. Might have dreamed of
Nerwen, but she said she wasn't terribly confident in her vote, so probably didn't.
Day 2
#178 - looks at
Nerwen's scenarios for
Pom's Day 1 motivation, and thinks the innocent-
McCaber option is most likely. Guilty
McCaber option is "is possible, but I don't find it very likely".
Hard to say from this whether she dreamed of McCaber. This is also phrased in uncertain terms. Perhaps there is something more concrete later.
#179 - doesn't think wolf-on-wolf votes are likely. Thinks if so would have been one of the earlier voters, and that
Sally and
Shasta would have had "to be very bold to throw a packmate under the bus like that so early in the game".
#187 - gives her impressions!
Nerwen - Likes her contribution that Day so far. (Indication that she dreamed of her?)
Morsul - thinks his actions are his playing style and that that tells us nothing of his role. (Definitely won't have dreamed of him.)
Sally - her vote for
Pom makes her think she's innocent. (Might have dreamed of her, but I doubt it.)
McCaber - leaning towards him being more innocent than not, because of
Pom's comment. She didn't find his vote very suspicious. (So, might have dreamed of him, but there's nothing clear.)
Gil - says that like
Morsul, his playing style looks suspicious regardless of role.
Inzil - "his behavior doesn't strike me as suspicious". (Probably didn't dream of him.)
Nogrod - "I'm not sure about Nogrod, but he's definitely one to watch." (Might have been planning to dream of him? Or might have already?)
Rikae - she has all sorts of positive things to say about
Rikae. I think she probably dreamed of her on Night 1.
Volo - "A bit suspicious".
Boromir - So far, sees no reason to suspect him. (But she obviously didn't dream of him.)
Copper - thinks I'm looking more likely to be innocent based on
Pom's vote. (But I doubt she'd have bothered to dream of me.)
Oz - is suspicious of him. But we know she didn't dream of him.
Lottie - "I don't see anything suspicious in her posts and her vote makes her look even less suspicious. I'm leaning towards probably innocent.". (Might have dreamed of her?)
Bane: - didn't say much.
Greenie: - "So far, I'm thinking she looks more on the innocent side." based on her vote and interactions. (Dreamed of her? I'd guess not, but she might have.)
Kath: - didn't say much.
Shasta - his vote "makes it seem unlikely that he isn't innocent". (Could be a dream? But I doubt it.)
None of that except the
Rikae thing stands out, and even that could plausibly be based on non-clever-trolliness. If she stays positive about
Rikae, she probably did dream her on Night 1.
#199 - thinks that the Cobbler-Nog theory is good. So she probably didn't dream of him?
I'll just quote her next list.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brinniel
Looking Innocentish
Sally
Rikae
Copper
Greenie
Shasta
Feeling Okay About
McCaber
Inzil
Loslote
Not Sure
Nerwen
Morsul
Gil
Boromir
Kath
Will Keep an Eye On
Nogrod
Bane
Looking Suspicious
Volo
Oz
|
Her looking suspicious list there...might indicate that she dreamed of
Volo, but I'd guess not. This is hard. I can see why the wolves didn't peg her as the clever troll earlier. So, maybe the key is somewhere in Day 3.
#178 - comments on
Oz and
Morsul. Might be defending
Morsul?
#212 - something
Nog says makes her think better of him as it sounds like "typical Nog". Of
Nerwen, says that "I certainly don't trust Nerwen, though at this point I no longer find her all that suspicious. Which is why I placed her in my "Not Sure" category.".
That's hard to interpret. Could indicate that she dreamed of her, but might not.
#123 - votes
Volo.
And that's the end of Day 2 for
Brin. I'll probably come back in a while to look at Day 3.
Conclusions so far: I think she dreamed of
Rikae Night 1, but I'm really not sure about who it might be on Night 2.