Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lommy
Speaking of psychics, Shasta will use half of his posts for praising Nerwen (and vice versa, but he always seems to be the one to start).
|
And why shouldn't I? We were married, once.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Kitanna
Lots of talk about the Maniac. But it looks like the role is a wildcard innocent. A chaotic good perhaps? Or maybe chaotic evil if the Maniac chose to align with the wolves. (Oh my, I wish my friend had never taught me how to play D&D. It's infiltrating my life.)
|
First major thought.
Inzil just got through saying the Maniac is in with the village - why would
Kitanna mention the possibilty of them aligning with the wolves?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
2. How Boro's important point was totally lost under a more or less odd discussion of whether the maniac is playing for the goodies or baddies... where the former, I think, was the obvious answer - and seems to be it. But what Boro said merits repeating: as we don't want to lynch the maniac (the danger for us is in lynching her/him) but want her/him killed by the wolves by Night (to take one of them with her/him for sure) - the wolves might like to impersonate the maniac trying to avoid lynching that way.
|
Second major thought - I approve of
Nogrod bringing this back up; consequently I also approve of
Boro bringing it up in the first place, obvious though it may have been. Side thought - it might be interesting to see who was the first to, as
Nog said, bury it under the discussion about the Maniac's allegiance. Lemme scroll up - hm. It ends up being
Lommy, followed by
Legate and
Nerwen.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Greenie
How do you impersonate a Maniac? I mean, if the Maniac plays for the village they'd want to get Night-killed, right? Which would mean they might try to impersonate the Seer, which would mean the wolves would try to impersonate the Maniac who tries to impersonate the Seer who tries to impersonate... I mean, maybe you others can follow this, but I can't, at least not this tired. Anyway what I'm saying is that catching someone "impersonating the Maniac" is easier said than done.
|
A fair point, but there's no real reason not to talk about it, especially this early.
Lommy floats the idea of the Maniac revealing. Gut reaction - I don't like it. If the Maniac reveals, the wolves won't attack them (and thus lose one of their number). We'd have a known innocent, sure - but is that worth it?
(
Greenie mentions the same in #32.)
Legate coming down on the side of the plan makes me twitch a bit, especially since he crossed with
Lommy nixing her own plan.
Done with page 1. As of now my gut tells me to vote
Kitanna or
Lommy, possibly
Legate, but this readthrough has been very rushed.