Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerwen
denethor, it's been been pretty well established that Tom is *meant* to be an enigma, so I don't think it makes much sense to claim that he's "really" any given thing.
Or are you just suggesting this as a way he could *theoretically* fit into Middle-earth? I mean without that being "the answer"?
|
It seems to me that Tom
could be a Maia, or perhaps better an Ainu, since the name
Maia refers to one of the People of the Valar and that doesn’t fit well with Tom.
Nor do we know in what sense Tom was an Enigma. I can imagine Tolkien quite willing to accept Tom as a creature of the Maia type. The Enigma part would come from how Goldberry and River-woman fit it.
But of course Tolkien did not say, seemingly on purpose. Mahgain’s post points out that beings of the Valar and Maia type are not the only spirits in Tolkien’s Middle-earth.