Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Green
The Ranger only gets their double protect after they're returned from the dead, right? So it won't last long since the Ranger's identity becomes pretty obvious once they're resurrected. And I assume they can't resurrect twice?
|
Ahhh, right you are. Never mind then- the Ranger isn't such a powerhouse then, at least not now. I suppose that means more than ever the Seer is the
only viable target at this time.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Green
So do the dead vote for a living player or double that player's vote? I interpreted it as the former (the Dead Thread vote being simply a ++person-of-their-choice) but the way I understood phantom's theory above, he seems to have interpreted it as the latter (the person chosen by the Dead gets to vote twice). The wording of the rules could mean either.
|
I see what you mean. Well, we could still pass info even if it's interpreted the other way, right? It would just require some tweaking. (I was interpreting it the one way because that's how it worked in the other village where we did this, wasn't it?)
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mac
All this trying to arrange an information flow with the dead... elaborate stuff like that never works.
|
Well yeah, it definitely won't work if we assume it won't and don't try it.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mac
you always have some people who vote right at the deadline or didn't get a chance to read everything and vote uninformed
|
That's their problem. If people play poorly and screw up well-intentioned plans then we should lynch them (because they might be WWs messing up on purpose). If it turns out to be innocents that are messing things up for us, then at least they'll know it was their fault we lost.
I mean really- we're not going to attempt something useful because we're afraid our own side will suck too much to pull it off? No, no, I'm not okay with that.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mac
This I don't get, or maybe I'm missing something. The dead can only find out roles among themselves, and do not see gifteds. They won't know who the real seer is, at least not for certain.
|
If the person doesn't appear as Predator then we trust the reveal, right?