On Nilp
#122 -
Nilp's first post of the game that references him being suspicious of anyone, calling out
Mac for
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nilp
pooh-poohing (is that a word? It is now!) phantom's plan of transferring information from the Dead to the Living without suggesting an alternative or even a modification to the original.
|
It's interesting to me that
Mac is the first person
Nilp elects to go after, given what we (think we) know about
Mac now. It's hard to say - I certainly wouldn't put it past
Nilp to suspect his packmate, but the feel of the suspicion here (based as it is on information) feels genuine. Of course, we have two wolfpacks, so it being a genuine suspicion doesn't in and of itself absolve
Nilp of wolfery... bah. Moving on.
#210 -
Nilp's first list. There's a bit of a sameness to this list, honestly, between people he's neutral (?) on and people he has no read on. The only definitive people he might suspect here, as far as I can tell, are -
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nilp
Swarm of killer beers [sic]
Aganzir
Thinlómien - The Finnish friends' little spat... well, they are friends, and I generally have a shorter fuse when it comes to my friends. But I echo others' sentiment that it looks Wolf-on-Wolf. (Remember, 'Wolf-on-Wolf' in this village doesn't necessarily mean 'artificially contrived'. Two Packs!) I trust Lommy more because list.
Nogrod - Oh, man... I initially had him in the previous section (pulling out the Voltaire quote even), but... his vehement argument against some form of clue-giving between the living and the Dead is troubling. Post-Mandos game trauma?
|
Agan and
Lommy had been talked about for most of the latter part of the day, as I recall. As far as
Nog goes, I think this might be a teensy bit of misrepresentation.
Nog surely wasn't shy about pointing out the possible pitfalls of a plan (that's a lot of p's) to derive information from the dead thread, but I don't know if I'd go so far as to say he was arguing against doing it entirely.
Day 2:
#255 -
Nilp is less certain that
Nog was evil (possibly just stubborn). Also,
Agan might exonerated on the grounds that
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nilp
Anyway, surely, no one can be that blatantly evil, especially in a game like this, where losing one of the Pack would put the rest under immense pressure to catch an opposing Baddie. Probably.
|
#377 -
Nilp's second list. The only person he's suspicious of is
Agan. Again,
Agan was pretty much the lynch target du jour all day long -
Nilp does have this to say regarding his own reason for voting her, however;
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nilp
Aganzir - I have an evil(!) idea drafted called 'Agan as test case' where knowledge of her role and Nogrod would help clear up plenty of confusion regarding yesterDAY's vote. Since she remains fairly suspicious, I'd not mind going through with this plan. I'd most likely vote for her toDAY
|
Still, I find it a tad strange how seemingly detached he is.
I'll cut this short and post it so people can start reading - it's only 2 hours till deadline and people have probably been posting while I've been doing this, so I'll need to read that, too...