Quote:
Originally Posted by Urwen
I think Pippin is 'I', because there is no mention of him revealing a bridge.
Unless you mean that his actions prompted Gandalf to hurry and reach the bridge, in which case, he would be 'you'.
Which further proves my theory that it could be Denethor, who tried to burn his own son alive.....
|
Just saw this edited version. Still confused about why you think Denethor. Still urge you to read the riddle carefully and map out what you know about "you" and "I", cause you seem to be jumping between them within the first statement.
Let's see if you can trace the second person back from what you already know. It might help you to get the exact details that are relevant to Pippin's part in the story (e.g. what is his shot? What was revealed?); once you have that straight it will be easier to place him into a I/you role, and thus make it easier to solve the remaining one.