Hmm that works too, but not what I was thinking. I find it hard to come up with "Odd Man Out"s with only 1 correct answer.
How's this - you could add Fingolfin to the group, and HE didn't go to Doriath (that I know of).
Perhaps it would be better to say that 4 of these guys had a certain (bad) experience, the 5th did not (at least, in the Silm).
[ April 25, 2002: Message edited by: Turambar ]