alatar, it seems to me you repeat the mistake the show caller made - how exactly Eru's omniscience differs from real world God's omniscience?
Indeed, did Eru 'play the game' once, or was it a rather a 'theme' - a rehearsal, a plan, rails along which the train of the world would move?
I can't see 'difference of ideologies' here. The 'rehearsal' was made for Ainur's sake, to let
them see what it was all about, to give them 'general idea', not to help Eru see what He was doing.
Besides, terms 'first time', 'second time' seem inapplicable to me in the case - the Music was
before world's time, and if there is any other kind of time in the Halls of Eru we do not know.
I once made a following analogy, I believe it may be applicable here:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by HerenIstarion
I can suggest you another mental image of a man looking upon a rope stretched on the table. Both, table (space) and rope (time), are made by man (God), but man is not bound to be inside either. The picture is lame for if any ant (human, elf) was to move along the rope, it would imply some passage of time by itself. But if there was no time for a man (God) than he would be able to see an ant (human, elf) at any given moment of it’s progress along the rope (time). Neither it means that watching ant crawling along the line is somehow influencing it’s progress, i e 'predestining' it
|
Coming from
Halls of Mandos and Elvish Free Will.
Let's further tune the image by saying Man at the Table may be seeing an Ant for each given moment of it's progress along the Rope, but all individual Ants are, in fact, same Ant stretched through the length of the Rope-Time.