#486
Examines "
Glirdy-wagon", wondering "were the wolves trying to save
Sally or are the wolves having a nightmarish start to the game?" Looks at the implications for
Glirdan-voters in the scenarios that
Glirdan was guilty and that he was innocent. If innocent, all three would look bad; if guilty,
Lommy would look good but
Skip and
Inzil not so much, especially
Zil.
#488. Clarifies a sentence in previous post.
#490
Looks at "those who walked their own paths" by not voting the favourites (
Greenie, Agan, Shasta and
Mira.) Finds all their votes somewhat suspicious and "would bet a lot for there being a wolf in this group - like in the group of Glirdy-voters".
#491
Looks at the
Sally-voters.
His own vote,
Brinn's, Legate's and
winty's look good;
mine and
Morsul's could go either way;
Glirdy's was just self-preservation "whatever his role"; no comment on
Nienna.
Comments: What's wrong with this post? Nothing– except that
eight people voted
Sally. How often has there
not been a wolf in a bandwagon that big? And yet, he's "betting" on there being wolves only in the other, smaller groups.
#514.Announces he's back.
#521
Discusses
Nienna, whose vote sealed
Sally's fate
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
Now if Glirdan is innocent that looks quite good (which doeasn't mean Nienna couldn't have done it as a wolf) but if Glirdy is a wolf it tells us nothing.
|
–Finds
Skip's defence of
Glirdan "interesting", but only from the point of view that a
Skipwolf would be afraid of having
Glirdan lynched and shown to be
innocent, thus exposing
Skipwolf's evil intentions in voting him.
Comments: The first point is fine, though it's odd that the voter who did most to kill the wolf is the one he seems to find least innocent. The other is just weird– really contorted reasoning. Why couldn't they
both be wolves? Isn't that the
first thing that springs to mind? (He does mention that possibility a bit later, but only in passing.)
#525
Responding to
Agan, says that
Greenie's suspicion of him is probably just due to her desire to be original, or because she read his comments to Sally "in some idiosyncratic fashion", or because he has been "a little less in the frontline this time", or because "in the end she has not played that many games with me". Doesn't suspect her much, but questions her shifting attitude to
Glirdan. Is suddenly talking about
Glirdan as though he knows he's a wolf– however, this is probably just for the sake of the argument, though he doesn't state that.
–Agrees with
Zil that he'd find him suspicious whether
Glirdan was innocent or guilty.
Comments: Naturally, anyone would want to defend himself when another player expresses strong suspicion– yet this way of smoothly explaining away
Greenie's attack to a third party does look more than a bit sinister in the light of her role.
#529Praises
Shasta for spotting an odd similarity in the wording of
Agan and
Legate's vote-posts:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
There is at least the shared kind of lazyness "you all know he is suspicious so I'll just vote him for it and not bother to make my points against him".
|
#539
Votes
Glirdan (
Glirdan 4) but is not happy with this, pointing out that
Sally and
Glirdan's early bantering was just IC and that
Glirdan tends to be a suspicion magnet. Says it would be useful to know his alignment however. Says Innocent!
Glirdan would make
Lommy, Zil and
Skip look bad, while Wolf!
Glirdan would make
Shasta, Mira, Greenie and
Agan look bad.
#541
"Undecided" about
Mira, finds
Greenie "innocentish".
General Comments: well, he doesn't come out of it looking nearly as bad as
Glirdan did when I analysed him– but on the whole I'd say he's "leaning furry".
EDIT:X'd since
Morsul at #597.
EDIT2:word left out.