Quote:
Originally Posted by Ivriniel
Do you think Bombadil's "Girdle" around the old forest likens itself to the Girdle of Melian?
|
It doesn't seem that Bombadil himself affects those wondering into the Old Forest.
When Frodo and his friends enter the Forest with a direction in mind, it appears that it is the collective will of the wood (ultimately, the Willow-man?) that decides they should be forced toward the Withywindle.
When they are saved by Bombadil, he tells the hobbits that event was "no plan of his". If his aiding them was something he had not directed, then neither was their being in the
position to be rescued.
Also, the placing of a 'girdle' ala Melian would imply his claim of the Forest as a realm, and that was something contrary to his nature.