Quote:
|
She is still attempting to dominate the world (or at least her little part of it). It may not be 'blamable', but it is an atttempt at dominance over nature.
|
Yet domination is the realm of the Enemy, not of the elves; I guess we will have to agree to disagree on this one
.
Quote:
|
The only guarantee of victory is to take the Ring
|
I doubt there is any power in Middle Earth who could wield the ring and achieve a _desireable_ victory - the only outcome is another Sauron.
Quote:
|
I think this would apply to the pre-Rebellion Noldor only
|
It depends on which moment we decide the rebellion started; even if so, what Vanyar/Teleri object could match Celebrimbor's Ellesar(s)?