Quote:
Originally Posted by Findegil
A reason could be that he wanted to avoid the same storry for the wifes of Felagund and Turgon. When Anairė wife of Turgon stayed in Aman, the wife of Felagund had to go with him into Middle-earth.
Gildor Inglorion from LotR comes to mind another possible reason.
The question with this change is: do we keep the rescue of Idril during the crossing of the ice? Up to now I considered here being a small child at that point, but that might have been wrong from the start.
Respectfully
Findegil
|
I see nothing wrong with keeping the rescue of Idril, and judging by the NoME, Idril was definitely not a child, though she was young.
But I think we definitely have to change Elenwe > Alaire (I would avoid 'Anaire', as I stated in my previous reply), regardless of whether or not we reject the 'Elenwe dying at Helcaraxe' story.