and also, about feanor not giving the silmarils to save the trees. Feanor was at Valimar when they asked him to give up the silmarils for the two trees. In the text it says he thought about giving them to the valar. While this was happening Melko had been at Formenos, killed Finwe, and stole the Silmarils. He never said that the valar couldnt have the silmarils for the trees.
|