I remember seeing that “Can you find the Entwives?” topic on Minas Tirith back in 2003
After reading that post I went back and reread the book and failed to find any mention apart from one of the hobbits claiming to see a tree like creature.
I myself think that the original poster was just looking to get attention and pump up his post count. My question is why would you make such a statement and fail to give us proof
Quote”
Congratulations, you've made a compelling argument to NOT post my discovery here.
And true enough to my word, I have already narrowed it down sufficiently that careful readers should be able to find them now that they suspect they're there.
/end quote
If he had indeed found them he would have told us all exactly what paragraph he was reading.