An uncharacteristically brief interjection ...
I rather think that the problem here is the liberal use of words such as "fault" and "blame".
If a reader does not "get" what the author is trying to tell him or her, or if the "enchantment" is somehow broken, it is not necessarily the fault of either author or reader. It is simply that their views are, to some degree or other, incompatible, and that may well be for perfectly good reasons. It is not a matter of one or the other being wrong.
Some readers may well find a more fulfilling "enchantment" in stories other than LotR because those stories are expressed in terms with which they are more able to identify. Others may find that they have no need for "enchantment". Neither such approach, in my view, is a crime.
__________________
Do you mind? I'm busy doing the fishstick. It's a very delicate state of mind!
|