Quote:
Originally Posted by A Little Green
I don't think I get your trap for the Wolves -theory. If suspecting Manwë was a trap to lure the wolves out, it obviously worked, but wouldn't that mean Manwë is a wolf? I'm confused.
|
Yes, I meant unless in case if
Mänwe was not a Wolf and
Shasta just wanted to try to lure the WWs out, and they then attacked him either randomly or with some different purpose, like to frame innocent
Mänwe. But anyway, of course most likely is that he is one of them and either was dreamed about or at most being lured out (if e.g.
Shasta perhaps dreamed of somebody who died that Night, or something).
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boromir88
Why are we assuming he's dreamed of Manwe? When he begins yesterday with no one in his "red" meter?
|
Because if he put only one person into his "red" box, it would be clear to the WWs that he is the Seer, especially if
Mänwe is one of them.
Shasta obviously wanted to stay hidden still. Of course, it was not much more subtle (from the WWs' perspective) to go after
Mänwe in such way, but he did also another analysis of
Cailín and made all these "announcements" that he is going to look at this one and that one toDay in his beginning post of the Day. And when
Mänwe was not lynched normally, he perhaps hoped for not being discovered (since the idea was dismissed) while at the same time leaving a clear enough clue in case he died. Or this is the way I could imagine it.