Quote:
Originally Posted by William Cloud Hicklin
Tolkien nods here; because he also has Gandalf say [paraphrasing] "At first I thought it was one of the lesser rings, not such a big deal though still perilous for mortals in my eyes." I think he should have stuck with this line and not used the other, which creates the plot hole.
|
That would have been preferable. I have spend so many hours pondering what I had overlooked...