The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post

Lalwendë · 12-29-2012, 06:27 PM

Today I managed to bag the last Hobbit calendar in the Waterstones sale and ripped it open as soon as I got home, only to be struck by how similar the images were to what we saw on screen in the film. I suppose I should have expected it, given that these two great illustrators were involved once again. However, the art in the calendar isn't 'concept' art, it's pre-existing art, mostly from the books (and all the art in them is approved by the Estate, I believe CT also chose Lee to illustrate CoH).

One good example of art that comes close to what we see in the films is Howe's illustration of the Great Goblin:
Howe's Great Goblin

Grotesque and towering above the other goblins, but with skulls around his neck instead of that fleshy chin. And note the dwarf who looks very like the Dwalin we see in the film.

And what's this? Alan Lee's Great Goblin, also a towering monster:
Alan Lee's Great Goblin

I don't know if that's a baby sat by his feet, or if it's the 'goblin scribe' I liked from the film.

In the Michael Hague illustrated Hobbit (which I can't get down from the shelf because I have around 200 CDs perched in front) there's also another immense Great Goblin. So I think we can lay to rest that the enormous one we saw in the film was just one man's vision!

I have also located a nice tumblr blog with a lot of Howe and Lee's art, both in general and also their concept art, and a quick look at this will demonstrate the extent to which they were involved in creating the film. To be honest I was a bit taken aback as it's clear they created an incredibly large swathe of it, and I don't think it can rightly be called Jackson's vision, because it's not! Take a look:

http://alan-and-john.tumblr.com/tagged/The-Hobbit

When Gandalf splits the rock at Trollshaws, this is Alan Lee's concept. The 'look' of Goblin town is down to Howe, as is Radagast's house. And the bluff where the Eagles take the company is clearly based on the Alan Lee book illustration.

And as a final and slightly irrelevant note, something which pleased me is that the Lego Bag End set is obviously based on the John Howe painting

12-29-2012, 06:27 PM	#1
Lalwendë A Mere Boggart Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: under the bed Posts: 4,737	Alan Lee & John Howe Art Today I managed to bag the last Hobbit calendar in the Waterstones sale and ripped it open as soon as I got home, only to be struck by how similar the images were to what we saw on screen in the film. I suppose I should have expected it, given that these two great illustrators were involved once again. However, the art in the calendar isn't 'concept' art, it's pre-existing art, mostly from the books (and all the art in them is approved by the Estate, I believe CT also chose Lee to illustrate CoH). One good example of art that comes close to what we see in the films is Howe's illustration of the Great Goblin: Howe's Great Goblin Grotesque and towering above the other goblins, but with skulls around his neck instead of that fleshy chin. And note the dwarf who looks very like the Dwalin we see in the film. And what's this? Alan Lee's Great Goblin, also a towering monster: Alan Lee's Great Goblin I don't know if that's a baby sat by his feet, or if it's the 'goblin scribe' I liked from the film. In the Michael Hague illustrated Hobbit (which I can't get down from the shelf because I have around 200 CDs perched in front) there's also another immense Great Goblin. So I think we can lay to rest that the enormous one we saw in the film was just one man's vision! I have also located a nice tumblr blog with a lot of Howe and Lee's art, both in general and also their concept art, and a quick look at this will demonstrate the extent to which they were involved in creating the film. To be honest I was a bit taken aback as it's clear they created an incredibly large swathe of it, and I don't think it can rightly be called Jackson's vision, because it's not! Take a look: http://alan-and-john.tumblr.com/tagged/The-Hobbit When Gandalf splits the rock at Trollshaws, this is Alan Lee's concept. The 'look' of Goblin town is down to Howe, as is Radagast's house. And the bluff where the Eagles take the company is clearly based on the Alan Lee book illustration. And as a final and slightly irrelevant note, something which pleased me is that the Lego Bag End set is obviously based on the John Howe painting __________________ Gordon's alive!