Quote:
|
I would say keep this scene and cut Galadriel's quote. Lorien's already the worst part of all three films anyway.
|
Good point, because overall this scene is well done. It gets the point across effectively and shows us the beginning corruption of Boromir towards the Ring. I just felt like it was unneeded because later we see this very thing. But this scene is definitely more subtle than Galadriel coming out and saying "He will try to take the Ring." So if I had a choice I agree, I would keep this one and cut out Galadriel only giving the whole thing away. This scene is much more subtle and keeps the suspense of what is happening between the Ring and Boromir, where Galadriel words basically just ruin it for us.