Lommy, making polls about what other people find suspicious makes me uneasy, too, for the reasons you mentioned (more to be found in various lorebooks). What I was expecting from you was your own thoughts of Villagers. The scheme seems helpful, but have you tried it yourself? If yes, did you manage to divide people to those different groups that you spoke of? I think that kind of discussion and analysing the villagers in general would be most useful in catching the baddies.
Something in
Lalaith is making me uneasy. I've tried analysing her posts, but I guess it's just the general impression than anything she'd have said directly that has caught my attention. Still, I'll take a moment to comment her posts.
#176 - the cannon fodder theory. The villager who was chosen by both Wizards is someone who'd make a good Seer.
I don't know if there is a villager who would at the same time be a good cannon fodder and Seer. The theory of making an expendable Wolf is interesting and something that the EW might try at some point, but considering that his/her job is to make as many wolves as s/he can, I don't think that sacrificing a wolf would be very profitable now that it's easy to hide among the masses.
#178 - asks when the sun will go down.
#180 - still confusion about the deadline, votes for
Loki because he filled the criteria of her cannon fodder theory.
She tied Loki with
Nogrod giving him a fifth vote.
#246 - several questions about rules.
Hmm, your ancestor suspected mine once for asking questions... should I suspect you?
- Says Sauce's death can be simply explained although then she wonders if she and
phantom are thinking along the same lines. She will keep her thoughts to herself, though. Says that no one is suspecting phantom, and she doesn't either although then she starts browsing old lorebooks.
Are you saying that there might reason to suspect phantom after all? As to the lorebooks, I kind of warned the Village about same thing yesterDay, but whatever.
- Doesn't agree with
Di and
Fea, and thinks that revealing the GW is a silly plan. Suspects Diamond for bad taste in music?
Would it be possible for you to give the quotes from Di and Fea? I'd appreciate that. Anyway, phantom has been pretty vocal about the benefits of the GW revealing themselves soon, so is there some reason why you chose to pick those two ladies?
"The wolves - there were only two last night and presumably they either came, via their mod, to some arrangement, or the EW picked one of their two choices, or the EW may even have made a few suggestions to them regarding their kill, if such things are permissible." ~Lalaith
According to the rules:
Order of Night Activities:
1. Evil wizard picks whom to curse.
...
7. Werewolves pick whom to kill.
I understand it that way that there were three Wolves making the decision of the kill.
I need a break. I'll be back later.
edit: some cross-posting.