The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - LotR2-TTT-Seq05

alatar · 03-08-2006, 01:16 PM

We feel the coming of a new day
Darkness gives way to light a new way
Stop here for a while until the world,
The world calls you away - Rivendell (Rush)

A spiked goblin head serves as a warning to all who pass by.

Floss!

Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli ride up to the smoldering mound of remains. Yuck! They immediately begin scanning the surroundings for some indication of the hobbits. Gimli prods the smoking pile with his axe and is rewarded for his persistence. An elvish sheath for one of the hobbits’ swords is found, and makes it seem all too certain that little bones are mingled with the Uruks. Legolas says something in his native tongue that I didn’t quite catch, then Aragorn punts a helmet in his anger/frustration.

Viggo actually broke his toe on this take, and PJ just thought that Viggo’d finally captured the emotion for the scene, but little did he know. Strider is brought to his knees, and yet, this is when he begins to find hope. A few bent blades of grass, a scuffmark or two, and Aragorn is putting the hobbit’s last night on the plain together, stitch by stitch.

The interspersing of Merry’s and Pippin’s run for Fangorn with Aragorn’s analysis is great, and you can see how the marks are made and what Aragorn is reading in to them. The close and far (above) shots are nice, as you are oriented as to the locale.

Aragorn sure knows a lot about tracking, as it almost seems that he’s watching the same cut scenes as us - I have no idea otherwise how he knows so much. Ranger indeed.

Merry and Pip running under a horse is something to see, and I wonder if the horse, if real, is inordinately tall for the stunt. As the pace of the hobbits’ escape accelerates (concurrent with Aragorn’s analysis), you begin to hear the quickening musical score (drums?) in the background. The wall of trees stops the Three Hunters, but not the hobbits or the orcs that stalk them.

Fangorn is a real and scary place, especially as the hobbits enter the old forest during the night. The twisted trunks and tangled roots and greenish mist make an alien, organic plant world. The trees look like anti-bonsais, twisted yet gigantic as they are. Before the hobbits can take it all in, guess who shows up? Remember what I said about a character making a declaration that very shortly thereafter is proven in error? No, you did not lose the orc.

Merry and Pippin run further and further into Fangorn as they try to stay ahead of the head-jerking and now zombified orc. The orc orders them to “Come here,” and he’s about as successful as any parent chasing toddlers. And just why would we stop, as weren’t you the guy that wanted our legs to eat? At least by running they’ll be a bit thinner.

Now where are those elven cloaks that seem to work so well in dirt? Wouldn’t this be the exact kind of place that they would be useful?

Merry gets the bright idea to head for higher ground, thinking that the orc won’t climb a tree. In the books the orcs didn’t climb the trees in Lothlorien, but I think that this was due to the vigilance and camouflage of the elves. Now PJ’s orcs can climb up and down vertical stone walls, and so you’d think that even the southern variety, which I think is this one’s place of origin, could handle a few branches to catch some tasty hobbits. But anyway, we just have to get the hobbits in the trees, don’t we?

The tree chosen by Pip looks none the different from any other, and though we will see in a moment that there’s something special about this tree, I just wonder why the tree has a small branch sticking out about 3 feet (1 meter) from the ground. Will this limb appear later when we see the ‘tree?'

Now Merry does it again, stating that the orc is “gone.” Any guesses what will happen next? Like the swimmer in “Jaws,” Merry is suddenly pulled from below, and we see that it’s his ‘gone’ orc buddy, as if there was any surprise there. Pip looks on as Merry is dragged from his perch. Thankfully Merry resists, and a fight ensues, but it doesn't go well.

Pip yells, and suddenly eyes appear in the tree on which he hangs. Pip actually is clinging to the Ent’s nose. A low rumble drags Pipis gaze from Merry back to the tree, and it’s then that he realizes that it’s not a tree. He lets go and falls earthward, but is saved by the Ent. Too bad that, as it looked like Pip, being Pip, was about to fall atop the orc, who was about to perforate Merry. Sure, Pip’s would probably slay the orc, but Merry would suffer too, as that’s just the way things work for Pip.

While the orc monologues, a large branchy foot/leg rises above him, and then it’s too late to run. Squash! Merry runs for it; bravely Pip tells him to get out of there and to leave him, but the merry little hobbit is no natural sprinter and is easily overtaken and captured by the Ent.

Note that the Ent’s leg does not have that little limb anymore.

Like King Kong, the Ent holds the two hobbits in the clutches of its huge hands. Its first assessment of the hobbits is that they are orcs. But instead of smashing them, the Ent engages in conversation, trying to educate the little orcs about trees and Ents - not that Merry is completely ignorant of the subject.

We learn that Treebeard is on no one’s side because no one is on his side, most likely as Treebeard’s default action is to stomp things that look anything remotely close to orcs. Learning that they are ‘hobbits,’ Treebeard assumes that they are lying (I guess), starts ranting about the foul folk and begins to squeeze the two. How friendly! Hopefully this thinking/spirit will be present when 10,000 confirmed non-little orcs are marching across the countryside.

If you’re looking for a target more your size, big guy…

A quick aside: I didn't like PJ's portrayal of the Ents. I expected something a little more man-like, and to have Treebeard allow the hobbits/orcs to climb his body...and though John Rhys-Davies voice is great, the ents are too CG/animatronic for me.

Merry continues to argue that he is not a little orc. Treebeard’s only half right - and remains unconvinced that these aren’t orcs. He decides to take them to the ominous White Wizard (can’t help it, but when I hear “white wizard” I think “White Wedding” by Billy Idol). The hobbits guess that they are going to see Saruman, and though they escaped the Uruks, it seems that there’s no escaping the White Wizard’s web.

The scene closes with the hobbits cast at the feet of the White Wizard. What will happen to poor Merry and Pippin next?

03-08-2006, 01:16 PM	#1
alatar Doubting Dwimmerlaik Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Heaven's basement Posts: 2,499	LotR2-TTT-Seq05 We feel the coming of a new day Darkness gives way to light a new way Stop here for a while until the world, The world calls you away - Rivendell (Rush) A spiked goblin head serves as a warning to all who pass by. Floss! Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli ride up to the smoldering mound of remains. Yuck! They immediately begin scanning the surroundings for some indication of the hobbits. Gimli prods the smoking pile with his axe and is rewarded for his persistence. An elvish sheath for one of the hobbits’ swords is found, and makes it seem all too certain that little bones are mingled with the Uruks. Legolas says something in his native tongue that I didn’t quite catch, then Aragorn punts a helmet in his anger/frustration. Viggo actually broke his toe on this take, and PJ just thought that Viggo’d finally captured the emotion for the scene, but little did he know. Strider is brought to his knees, and yet, this is when he begins to find hope. A few bent blades of grass, a scuffmark or two, and Aragorn is putting the hobbit’s last night on the plain together, stitch by stitch. The interspersing of Merry’s and Pippin’s run for Fangorn with Aragorn’s analysis is great, and you can see how the marks are made and what Aragorn is reading in to them. The close and far (above) shots are nice, as you are oriented as to the locale. Aragorn sure knows a lot about tracking, as it almost seems that he’s watching the same cut scenes as us - I have no idea otherwise how he knows so much. Ranger indeed. Merry and Pip running under a horse is something to see, and I wonder if the horse, if real, is inordinately tall for the stunt. As the pace of the hobbits’ escape accelerates (concurrent with Aragorn’s analysis), you begin to hear the quickening musical score (drums?) in the background. The wall of trees stops the Three Hunters, but not the hobbits or the orcs that stalk them. Fangorn is a real and scary place, especially as the hobbits enter the old forest during the night. The twisted trunks and tangled roots and greenish mist make an alien, organic plant world. The trees look like anti-bonsais, twisted yet gigantic as they are. Before the hobbits can take it all in, guess who shows up? Remember what I said about a character making a declaration that very shortly thereafter is proven in error? No, you did not lose the orc. Merry and Pippin run further and further into Fangorn as they try to stay ahead of the head-jerking and now zombified orc. The orc orders them to “Come here,” and he’s about as successful as any parent chasing toddlers. And just why would we stop, as weren’t you the guy that wanted our legs to eat? At least by running they’ll be a bit thinner. Now where are those elven cloaks that seem to work so well in dirt? Wouldn’t this be the exact kind of place that they would be useful? Merry gets the bright idea to head for higher ground, thinking that the orc won’t climb a tree. In the books the orcs didn’t climb the trees in Lothlorien, but I think that this was due to the vigilance and camouflage of the elves. Now PJ’s orcs can climb up and down vertical stone walls, and so you’d think that even the southern variety, which I think is this one’s place of origin, could handle a few branches to catch some tasty hobbits. But anyway, we just have to get the hobbits in the trees, don’t we? The tree chosen by Pip looks none the different from any other, and though we will see in a moment that there’s something special about this tree, I just wonder why the tree has a small branch sticking out about 3 feet (1 meter) from the ground. Will this limb appear later when we see the ‘tree?' Now Merry does it again, stating that the orc is “gone.” Any guesses what will happen next? Like the swimmer in “Jaws,” Merry is suddenly pulled from below, and we see that it’s his ‘gone’ orc buddy, as if there was any surprise there. Pip looks on as Merry is dragged from his perch. Thankfully Merry resists, and a fight ensues, but it doesn't go well. Pip yells, and suddenly eyes appear in the tree on which he hangs. Pip actually is clinging to the Ent’s nose. A low rumble drags Pipis gaze from Merry back to the tree, and it’s then that he realizes that it’s not a tree. He lets go and falls earthward, but is saved by the Ent. Too bad that, as it looked like Pip, being Pip, was about to fall atop the orc, who was about to perforate Merry. Sure, Pip’s would probably slay the orc, but Merry would suffer too, as that’s just the way things work for Pip. While the orc monologues, a large branchy foot/leg rises above him, and then it’s too late to run. Squash! Merry runs for it; bravely Pip tells him to get out of there and to leave him, but the merry little hobbit is no natural sprinter and is easily overtaken and captured by the Ent. Note that the Ent’s leg does not have that little limb anymore. Like King Kong, the Ent holds the two hobbits in the clutches of its huge hands. Its first assessment of the hobbits is that they are orcs. But instead of smashing them, the Ent engages in conversation, trying to educate the little orcs about trees and Ents - not that Merry is completely ignorant of the subject. We learn that Treebeard is on no one’s side because no one is on his side, most likely as Treebeard’s default action is to stomp things that look anything remotely close to orcs. Learning that they are ‘hobbits,’ Treebeard assumes that they are lying (I guess), starts ranting about the foul folk and begins to squeeze the two. How friendly! Hopefully this thinking/spirit will be present when 10,000 confirmed non-little orcs are marching across the countryside. If you’re looking for a target more your size, big guy… A quick aside: I didn't like PJ's portrayal of the Ents. I expected something a little more man-like, and to have Treebeard allow the hobbits/orcs to climb his body...and though John Rhys-Davies voice is great, the ents are too CG/animatronic for me. Merry continues to argue that he is not a little orc. Treebeard’s only half right - and remains unconvinced that these aren’t orcs. He decides to take them to the ominous White Wizard (can’t help it, but when I hear “white wizard” I think “White Wedding” by Billy Idol). The hobbits guess that they are going to see Saruman, and though they escaped the Uruks, it seems that there’s no escaping the White Wizard’s web. The scene closes with the hobbits cast at the feet of the White Wizard. What will happen to poor Merry and Pippin next? __________________ There is naught that you can do, other than to resist, with hope or without it.