View Single Post
Old 11-08-2015, 04:59 PM   #18
Faramir Jones
Ghost Prince of Cardolan
 
Faramir Jones's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Lonely Isle
Posts: 706
Faramir Jones is a guest at the Prancing Pony.Faramir Jones is a guest at the Prancing Pony.
Thumbs up Some impressions of Oxonmoot 2015

As Aganzir, The Might (whom I had the pleasure of meeting for the first time!), and Pervincia Took have talked about their impressions of the 'moot, I'll add my (very belated) ones.

Before it took place on the Thursday, I arrived a few days earlier in Oxford, to have a look around at some of the other sights before attending. One thing I saw was particularly relevant, in the Bodleian Library's 'Marks of Genius' exhibition:

http://genius.bodleian.ox.ac.uk/

One of the many interesting items on display was Tolkien's dust-jacket design for The Hobbit, which was done by him in full size.

Other items of interest included the manuscript of Kenneth Graham's The Wind in the Willows, and the first of the series of letters to his son, which was the genesis of that work. Also, there were first edition copies of the first 6 of Jane Austen's published works, open at the first page of Pride and Prejudice, with an explanation that the Bod didn't acquire them at the time of publication, then regarding novels as trashy things only women read, and unworthy of being in a great library!

St. Antony's College, where the 'moot was held, while exceedingly young by Oxford standards (1950), impressed me. The staff I had dealings with were very helpful, and I was impressed by the quality of my room. Also, everything, except for the art show, was quite close together. Perhaps it was the fact that the college is for postgraduate study, and has particular interests in international relations, politics and economics.

I later heard that of the people registered for the 'moot, 45 were first timers, to whom I tried to be friendly, as well as renewing acquaintances with my fellow 'old timers'. It was nice to later hear from 2 of the first timers that they'd decided to come to the next 'moot!

As Aganzir said, as well as herself and myself, there were Kath, Hookbill, The Might, Poison Ivy, Pervincia Took and narfforc among the participants, as well as the later joined Scilens, to whom I again say welcome!

After dinner on the Thursday, there was shown a video of Brien Sibley, unable to come to the 'moot, but who sent his best wishes, talked about his own experience with Tolkien's works, his experience with Peter Jackson's films of same, and showed his copy of The Adventures of Tim Bombadil, signed both by JRRT and by Pauline Baynes:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rybQha_mY_E

Later, from about 10 to 11.40 p.m., followed the pub quiz. We had a full schedule on Friday and Saturday, with one stream of activities. I was in the lecture theatre Friday morning, and listened to the first three talks, being the steward on duty there: Irina Metzer about comparisons between Rivendell and the stories of Shangri-La, to which I contributed; Ashna Jacob about comparisons between The Hobbit and Amish Tripathi's Shiva Trilogy, which sounded interesting to me, but was hampered by my ignorance of the latter's works; and Joel Cornah's about Tolkien and Dr. Who, very well received and publicised:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4xGU...LMJZI8CAge-Kvk

My own talk was at 3.10 that afternoon. There were 55 people present in the theatre, and it was well received, judged by the questions and comments afterwards. A good one on the Mouth of Sauron by Chris Melville followed.

I also enjoyed the next lecture, by Maria Alberto on 'Seduction in Tolkien's work'. There was supposed to be a debate, 'Jackson made Lord of the Rings for the fans and The Hobbit for the studio'; but it had been cancelled, as only one person volunteered, who had offered to speak on the against side (me!).

Saturday morning, I was again in the lecture theatre. I got the last part of Jessica Yates's talk on Tolkien and Shakespeare, was around for Elise McKenna's comparison of Tolkien and Joseph Campbell; and was particularly impressed by Dimitra Fimi's talk on 'Representations of Childhood in Tolkien':

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nWU89Hnp_JE

This was in my opinion, and it appears in those of others, the best talk at the 'moot.

Lunch that day was interesting, as a few things happened. Society Chairman Shaun Gunner spoke; length of membership badges were given out to those (including me) who wanted them given at the 'moot; two portraits were auctioned; a presentation was made to Shaun; flowers were given to Oxonmoot Chair Elena Krysova; and Harm Schelhass offered an Unquendorian invitation to fans present to come to that society's 'moot.

I was on stewarding duties in the Ops Room for most of the afternoon. Regarding the Ents and Masquerade, Denis Bridoux and I did a sketch at around 5.25 p.m. Other items of interest there included the Entwives Sketch (with Ivy and Maggie Bailey); the Barmaid sketch by Angie Reynolds; the Dwarf Tossing, involving certain dwarves whose photo we've seen here; and the ending with Catherine Thorne singing 4 songs very nicely.

Then followed dinner in the Rose and Crown on North Parade, before I and others were back for the party. I later managed to have at least some hours' sleep before breakfast on the Sunday morning. There had been a pleasant announcement that as the cleaners were not coming in that day, we didn't have to (as usual) vacate our rooms by 10 a.m.

Later on the Sunday, we went to Enyalie as usual. Like Tolkien had Father Christmas say about Christmas, it's always the same and always different. Things were particularly moving when Shaun read out the bit from The Silmarillion about Luthien moving Mandos to pity, and the choice then given to her. This was in the context of absent friends, including Jef Murray.

On our return, after I said my farewells to people, leisurely packed and checked out, I went into town, to have lunch in the Lamb and Flag with some others. When lunch was finished, as I had a few hours before going on to Heathrow, I took advantage of Oxford Open Doors, and managed to get into 2 colleges: Oriel, then All Souls, which was very nice, before I left for Heathrow around 5 p.m., to get back to 'normal' life.
Faramir Jones is offline   Reply With Quote