Erm.. what the eff happened yesterDay?
Also, it seems I've been barking up the wrong tree for two Days. Sorry
Sally.
But why
Wilwa? What were the arguments against her? I should go back and check I suppose.
As for
Nog - it's possible that the elves read his "Leave that to the Seer" -comments as hints. It's pretty paranoid but elves are bound to be. As for
Nerwen's theory about him - well it's pretty clear that a
Nog-Seer's second dream would have been
phantom:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nog
Also, I think the phantom is innocent - and is no seer. If he wasn't dreamt of yet by the seer then now he is. So let's leave him be.
|
Which would logically mean that if the elves killed
Nog as a potential Seer,
phantom is innocent. It would be ingenious though for a
phantomelf and his pack to kill
Nog (who they would more or less know was not the Seer, but would be seen by the village as a potential one). A pretty perfect cover for a
phantomelf. Then again, a) I still believe
phantom is innocent, and b) the elves would have been plain crazy not trying to target the Seer last Night.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nerwen
The other, very outside possibility is that he "dreamed" Greenie as an Elf– see #407. However, the fact that Nog said no more of this, and was more than happy to lynch someone else should have tipped the Elves off, not to mention the fact that his actual "hint" posts (#391, #400, #469, #480) were all about the phantom and Sally. Still, Elves do panic sometimes.
|
This logic doesn't make sense to me. I know I'm not an elf but I also know you can't know it. The thing is, it doesn't make sense even if I was an elf. It would take a
ridiculously paranoid pack of elves to read #407 as a Seer hint, especially as
Nog didn't behave towards me in a manner that would suggest him "knowing" I was an elf.
Back in a dash with a few responses to what was said yesterDay..