[eleanor_niphredil]

the first thing that I have to say is that nobody claimed that the new movie was going to be exactly like the book. It says that it is BASED on the works of JRR Tolkien, which is exactly what it was.<P>If you can do better than PJ, then go ahead, be my guest. But I have to say that I loved the films, still love the films and always will love the films just as much as I love the book.<P>One thing that people forget, though, is that PJ is as much of a fan of Tolkien as we are. Otherwise he would never have attemted to make a film. To say that he did it incorrectly just to put his own twist on the story is, sorry to whoever said it, utterly rediculas. <P>Last I would like to remind you that PJ is a person, not just a character in some book. Nobody is perfect. So just, chill out, okay?